AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 132

by Angela Casella

I kiss her cheek. “Do you need help getting back to bed?”

She shoves my arm, scoffing. “I’m old, not dead.”

I text Emily and the others, letting them know I’m okay, but no one answers. My mind starts spiraling, filling with car wrecks and Krampus and every kind of Christmas calamity that could happen.

I stop by the farmhouse to grab a couple of things before heading to the bookstore—and immediately run into Theo, who’s getting out of his truck.

“Where were you?” he says, anger and fear rippling over his face.

I lift my hands. “I was out in the fields, and then I went to talk to Nonna Rose.”

He shocks me by pulling me into a tight hug. “Fuck, I thought you’d left us.”

“I almost did.” I hug him back. “I thought it might be better⁠—”

He pushes away, shaking his head. “It wouldn’t be better for anyone. I can’t do this without you, Miles.”

“Of course you could.”

I’m not seeking a compliment. He could. My big brother is the guy who does everything in a group project while everyone else coasts. And, sure, I’ve been working my ass off for the past couple of months, but it bears saying that he’s worked harder.

“But I don’t want to do it without you,” Theo says, his brow furrowing.

His words relieve me of a weight I hadn’t realized I was carrying. All this time, I figured I was a burden to my big brother. That it would be easier for Theo to go on managing things the way he always has—without my interference or off-the-wall ideas. But he really wants me here.

He claps me on the back. “Now, go. Get your girl.”

“Will you help me load the truck first? We’re supposed to give away all that mistletoe today.”

“You’ve only been back for a minute, and you’re already asking for favors,” he says with a smile. “I see how it is.”

“How about I tell you a little story while we do it.” I pause, wondering if this will fuck with him as much as it did me. “Turns out Uncle Ted is actually our grandfather.”

He hesitates, then asks, “How’d you find out?”

Well, shit, of course he knows. He’s the silent observer. The hard worker.

“It’s a long story, but Nonna Rose just told me.”

He nods once. “Does anyone else know?”

“Not yet. But they will. I think it’s past time we all stopped keeping secrets, don’t you?”

Each moment I spend in the truck feels like an eternity, partly because Mr. Campbell’s words are still echoing in my head.

I’m still not sure I’m doing what’s right. I want Emily to be happy and fulfilled more than I’ve ever wanted anything—and it would feel criminal to tear her away from the bookstore. But I can’t let her think I don’t love her. If I did, I know it would ruin me.

I park in front of the bookstore and grab my things before getting out.

The sky is turning pink, with bands of deep purple as I text Emily again.

Emily, are you home?

I’m so sorry I worried you.

We need to talk.

There’s no response, so I circle around the building, my heart in my throat, fucking choking me, because now I’m really worried.