AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 131

by Angela Casella

The Murphy Treasure.

No message is written on the actual stone this time, but my eyes feel hot again.

He did this for me, dammit. Because he cared about me.

“Read the note,” Nonna Rose says.

Miles-

I hope you don’t mind that your old uncle pulled one over on you, the way you’ve done to me a few times before.

The thing is, I know what it feels like to be your age and restless. It’s an awful thing, isn’t it?

I know you see me as boring old Uncle Ted, and I’ve given you no reason not to, but I got into my own scrapes when I was your age. Let’s just say you’re not the first Murphy to discover how easy it is to make moonshine.

Now, I know treasure sounds pretty good when you’re a young man wanting to make your mark, but the real treasure is something we already have here at Evergreens & Apples.

It’s our family. And it’s this beautiful place we were lucky enough to be born into. I don’t believe we truly own it, the way your grandfather does. I prefer to think of us as its caretakers.

Anyway, if you found this, then you’ll know your uncle got one over on you. If not, I think it’ll be a little secret I’ll keep with this clock.

Love,

Uncle Ted

I glance over at Nonna Rose, whose eyes are glazed with tears, her mouth tipped up in a small smile.

“He’s the man you loved,” I blurt.

I don’t know how I know, but I do. Maybe because I’m also in love with someone who wasn’t meant for me.

She nods slowly. “I will tell you something only Francesca knows.” A moment of silence passes before she finishes, “Your grandfather couldn’t have children, so he asked Ted for a favor.”

My mouth parts in shock.

“That’s why…” I mime throwing an apple. “Francesca does seem pretty old school.”

“Part of it, yes,” she says with a soft smile. “But I’m ashamed to say it’s not all of it. Ted and I got close that year, very close. We told ourselves we were only doing what we’d been asked. What Francesca disapproved of came later.”

Again, it takes her a moment to continue, her gaze far-off and unfocused on the Christmas tree. “For years, Ted and I stayed away from each other, but after your mother and your father divorced and you children came to stay here with her, Ted and I became close again. We fell in love.” She hesitates. “I told your grandfather I was going to leave him, but he begged us both to stay. Ted broke it off, and we agreed to his terms…although there were moments when we gave into our feelings. Now that they’re both gone, I wish things had been different. It would have been hard for both of us, but we missed out on something wonderful, and your grandfather wasn’t happy, either. We were all miserable, and for what?”

I’m in shock, but there’s no missing the message she’s shoving in my face. “You’re telling me to go after Emily.”

“I’m telling you, my boy.” She touches my cheek. “That you will always live with the pain of regret if you do not, and if you live long enough, your regrets may be all you’re left with. That’s no kind of life.”

“Nonna,” I say. “I wish⁠—”

“I know.” She pats my hair. “I wish he’d told you too. He loved you kids so much. He always believed in you, Miles, and I believe in you too. I know you’ll do what’s right.”

The box inside of me, which I’ve carried for so long, shakes to make its presence known. It’s not empty. It won’t ever be empty, but it’s open now, and there’s no closing it.

“But this isn’t…” I get up, because it feels ridiculous to sit down when life as you knew it is blasting apart. “This isn’t a situation where there’s an obvious right or wrong. Mr. Campbell told me he was going to give Emily the bookstore, but he won’t do it if I’m in her life. That’s her dream, Nonna Rose. I can’t rip that away from her.”

She looks me straight in the eye, way more intimidating than she should be for a small woman in curlers. “It wouldn’t be you ripping it away, Miles, it would be him. That choice is Lionel’s to make. But don’t take Emily’s choice away from her. If you love her, and you want to be with her, let her be the one to decide. I can only tell you how much I wish the same choice had been given to me.”

I study her for a moment, then pick up the ruby from the clock and stuff it into my pocket. “Nonna, I don’t know how this is all going to go down.”

“None of us do,” she says, then kisses her fingers and presses them to my cheek. “We can only trust in each other and in the truth in our hearts.”