Page 30
“Too much?” Mabel asked, frowning.
“No, it’s—” He coughed again. “It’s fine. Just caught me off guard is all.”
“That’s because you’re not used to inhaling Christmas cheer,” Mabel said with a knowing smile. “But you seem more receptive this year, I think. I wonder why that is.”
Her gaze moved pointedly between Nolan and Abigail, and Nolan felt his face heat. But when he looked at Abigail, she was smiling at him, and he found himself smiling back.
“I should check on something outside,” Mabel announced suddenly. “You two keep decorating. I’ll be back in a bit.”
And just like that, she was gone, leaving them alone with the half-decorated tree and the plate of cookies and the soft Christmas music playing from the radio.
“Looks like we’re on decorating duty,” Abigail said with a laugh, reaching for a string of lights. Nolan took another sip of the latte and picked up a sparkling, glittery silver ornament ball, feeling less put off by the whole thing than he usually was.
They worked in comfortable silence for a while, hanging ornaments and untangling lights. Nolan found himself relaxing more than he would have expected, the tension in his shoulders easing as he listened to Abigail hum along with the music. The music didn’t sound grating, like it usually did, and he caught himself more than once admiring the tree as it started to come together.
She picked up another ornament—a delicate glass ball with “Mabel & George’s First Christmas” painted on it in gold handwriting. Her smile faltered, and that shadow passed over her face again, lingering this time.
“You okay?” Nolan asked quietly.
“Yeah, I just—” She set the ornament down carefully. “I was supposed to have one of these. A ‘first Christmas’ ornament. I was supposed to be starting that part of my life.”
It was the closest she’d come to actually revealing what was hurting her, what had put her on the road to Portland that had ended with her broken down on the side of the road. Nolan didn’t know what to say, or how to make it better. So he did the only thing he could think of—he reached for more tinsel and gently tucked a piece behind her ear.
Abigail looked up at him, surprised, and then she laughed. It was a smaller laugh this time, tinged with sadness, but it was a laugh nonetheless. “What are you doing?”
“Making you smile,” he said, with a small smile of his own.
“Well, it’s working.” She laughed again, and reached for another ornament.
They continued decorating, and slowly, the shadow lifted from Abigail’s face. She told him a few stories about collecting ornaments with her mother and the boxes of them she had back home, and he reached back as far as he could for a happy Christmas story, remembering one Christmas before everything fell apart when he and his grandmother had decorated her tree together.
The Christmas cookies disappeared as they munched on them and drank their eggnog lattes. At some point, Mabel returned, but she didn’t interrupt. She just asked if they wanted more coffee and then disappeared again.
When the tree was finally finished, covered in ornaments and lights and entirely too much tinsel, they stood back to admire their work.
“It’s beautiful,” Abigail said softly. She turned to look at him, her expression soft and happier than he’d seen her since he’d found her on the side of the road. “Thank you for staying. For the cookies, and for making me laugh. I needed this more than you know.”
“I’m glad I stayed,” Nolan said, and realized he meant it. He’d come here planning to drop off cookies and leave, keep being the Grinch he’d always been.
But standing here with Abigail, with tinsel in her hair and a smile on her face, he realized suddenly that he didn’t want to leave.
For the first time in years, Nolan wanted to stay and keep enjoying Christmas.
CHAPTER THIRTEEN
Mabel stood at her kitchen sink, the window cracked open just enough to let in the crisp December air and, more importantly, to let her hear what was happening outside. She was filling the sink with warm soapy water, ostensibly washing lunch dishes, but her attention was focused entirely on the sounds drifting from the living room and listening for George to come home.
She could hear Abigail’s laugh, followed by Nolan’s deeper chuckle. The sound made Mabel’s heart swell with satisfaction. When she’d excused herself earlier to “check on something outside,” she’d really been setting up her latest prank on George. But she’d also been giving those two young people some time alone together, and from the sounds of it, they were getting along beautifully.
She dried her hands on a dish towel, smirking as she waited for her chicken prank to pay off. She’d rigged it on top of the roof over the doorway with fishing line and a motion sensor she’d found in George’s workshop. As soon as George showed up at the front door, the ridiculously realistic clucking sound would go off. Mabel glanced at the clock on the wall. 11:58. Any minute now, he’d be home for lunch.
Another round of laughter came from the living room, and Mabel smiled to herself. She’d known from the moment she’d seen Nolan standing on her doorstep with that box of cookies that something was different. Nolan didn’t do things like that. He didn’t buy Christmas cookies. He didn’t make social calls. He certainly didn’t show up with thoughtful gifts for women he barely knew.
But he’d done all of those things for Abigail.
And the way Abigail had looked at him when he’d put that tinsel in her hair—oh, Mabel had seen that look. She’d seen the way Abigail’s whole face had softened, the way her eyes had lit up.
Those two didn’t know it yet, but there was something there between them. Mabel could see it as clear as day. And if she had to do a little meddling to help them figure it out, well, it had definitely worked in the past. Just look at Imogen and Lincoln, she thought.