Page 29
“Nolan,” she said with a surprised smile. “I didn’t expect to see you today.”
He stood there in the doorway, suddenly, awkwardly aware of the cookie box under his arm. “I—” He cleared his throat. “I remembered what you said. About Mabel and George’s house seeming like the sort of place that would have cookies waiting.”
Abigail looked even more startled. “I did? Well, that does seem right,” she said with a small laugh.
“I thought that kind of perfectly described the town in general,” Nolan continued, clearing his throat awkwardly. “So I… figured I’d bring you some of the best. From the Snowdrift Diner. Jackson makes them fresh every morning. It’s their signature holiday thing, or whatever. He’s been doing it for years.”
Abigail’s smile brightened, and he felt something warm in his chest as she crossed the room and took the cookie box from him, her fingers brushing his for just a moment. She looked down at the cookies visible through the clear window, and her eyes went a little glossy.
“Nolan, this is—” Her voice caught. “This is so thoughtful. Thank you.”
“It’s just cookies,” he said gruffly, but he couldn’t quite hide his pleasure at her reaction.
“Well, you can’t just drop off cookies and leave,” Mabel announced, already heading toward the kitchen. “You have to stay and help us enjoy them. And I’ll make you an eggnog latte too. We were just starting to enjoy ours.”
“I don’t want to intrude—” Nolan started, but Abigail was already nodding, and her smile did something to his resolve.
“Please stay,” she said. “We’re decorating the tree, and it’s actually really fun. I’m enjoying the company so… the more the merrier, right?”
Mabel was already gone, the sound of her humming drifting from the kitchen, and Nolan knew he’d been outmaneuvered. But looking at Abigail, he found he didn’t mind as much as he should have.
“Alright,” he said. “For a little while.”
Abigail’s smile widened, and she set the cookie box on the coffee table, opening it carefully. “Oh, these look amazing. Look at the detail on this gingerbread man.”
Nolan shrugged off his coat and hung it by the door, then moved closer to the tree. He’d never been much for decorating—his own house had exactly zero Christmas decorations, and he liked it that way. But watching Abigail pick up an ornament, her brow furrowed as she looked for the perfect spot for it, he felt something in his chest warm.
“How’s the decorating going?” he asked, trying to sound casual.
“It’s actually really fun,” Abigail said, hanging a delicate glass snowflake on a branch. “Mabel has so many beautiful ornaments.”
There was something wistful in her voice, and Nolan saw a shadow pass over her face. It was just for a moment, but he caught it.
He wanted to ask what had happened, what had put that look in her eyes. But they didn’t know each other well enough for that, he was aware. She didn’t have any obligation to share with him what it was that had hurt her, and it wasn’t as if he’d told her his life story either. Nor did she probably want that added on to whatever was already bothering her.
But he did want that sound in her voice to be replaced with something happier. So instead, he reached into one of the boxes and pulled out a long strand of silver tinsel. “You’ve got some tinsel in your hair,” he said, moving closer.
“What?” Abigail’s hand went to her head. “Where?”
“Here.” Without thinking, Nolan reached out and gently placed a piece of tinsel in her hair, draping it over her ponytail like a shimmering ribbon.
Abigail’s eyes went wide, and then she laughed—a real, genuine laugh that lit up her whole face. “Did you just put tinsel in my hair?”
“Well, I said it, so I had to do something to make it true.”
She laughed again, reaching up to touch the tinsel. “You’re ridiculous.”
Nolan couldn’t help the smile that came to his lips. He hadn’t heard anyone say that in a long time. Grumpy, yes, Grinch-y, or gruff. But not ridiculous.
He liked the sound of it, he realized.
“Here.” She grabbed another piece of tinsel and, before he could protest, draped it over his shoulder. “Now we match.”
They stood there, grinning at each other, and Nolan felt a sudden urge to reach for her, to take her hand and pull her closer—
The sound of footsteps made him take a step back as Mabel returned with a mug of eggnog latte, her eyes twinkling as she took in the scene. “Well, don’t you two look festive. Here, Nolan, try this.”
He took the mug cautiously. It was topped with whipped cream and a dusting of what looked like cinnamon and nutmeg. He took a sip and immediately coughed, the spices hitting the back of his throat.