AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 13

by Ariana Kemp

Cohen looked so earnest as he observed me though. Whatever he found had his strong brow softening and head tilting to the side.

Lord, help soften my heart.

I grasped for more words, not sure how to articulate what I was feeling in a prayer, but settling on that simple phrase to cover the complexities warring inside of me.

“Thank you Cohen,” I finally spoke, well aware we had been standing in awkward silence for the better part of a minute. “If you really don’t mind, I’d appreciate the help.”

“I don’t say things I don’t mean.” He settled his hat lower again with a genuine grin. “I’d be happy to help. You mind if I prop your shop door open?”

“Go for it,” I waved him off. “There’s a huge rock with a butterfly painted on it to the right of the door. I typically use that.”

“Thank ya much.” He nodded his head in thanks before striding out of the room.

I let out the breath I had apparently been holding and leaned against the counter, a little laugh bubbling up. What a strange day.

I looked down at my hands, caked in bits of dough and I groaned, realizing I had shaken his hand like this. I moved over to the sink and washed them thoroughly, my hands tinged an irritated red from having to scrub the stubborn bits left on my skin.

As I moved over and finished kneading the dough, Cohen came in and out of the kitchen, each time neatly adding a few bags of flour to the pallet. I tried to tune him out, humming to myself and focusing on the task at hand, but every time he walked past me I lost track of my song.

The lilting smell of pine and mint would just barely reach me through the heavy cinnamon scent in the air coming from the oven. He somehow smelled like the outdoors and cleanliness, two things that I didn’t know came in a particular scent, yet I found them increasingly addictive. I had half a mind to shut off the oven so I could get more of it.

I stopped kneading as the familiar resistance beneath my palms signaled it was done. After years of baking, I timed nothing. I rarely measured. I knew my recipes and what they were supposed to feel like. They told me when to stop kneading or when to add more flour. It was all second nature at this point. I formed the dough into a tight ball and placed it in a greased bowl, moving it over to my proofing oven to rest with the other pastries I had prepped for tomorrow. When I turned around, wiping my hands on my apron, I found Cohen leaning against the doorway, his arms crossed over his chest.

My gaze drifted down to the way the position made the muscles in his forearms stand out. What did he do for a living for them to look like . . . that?

Cohen cleared his throat.

The earth could have swallowed me up right then, and I would have been okay with it. My cheeks to the tips of my ears were burning as I slowly looked up.

His shoulders shook lightly with obvious laughter as he reached up to rub his jaw, at least having the decency to pretend to cover his chuckle.

“I like your doorstop.” He cut through my embarrassment spiral as he nodded out toward the storefront, a lopsided smile on his lips. “Two-tailed swallowtail. Did you paint that?”

I couldn’t stop the massive smile and slight bounce on the balls of my feet if I tried. He knew butterflies?

“I did.” I clasped my hands together, trying to temper my excitement. “Do you like butterflies?”

“Do I like butterflies?” He grinned and nodded for me to follow him, pointing toward the small canvas paintings lining the hallway as he spoke. “Purplish copper, painted lady, indra swallowtail, sagebrush checkerspot, melissa blue, and let us not forget our little moth friend you snuck in there—American lappet moth.”

Forget being handsome, he knew his butterflies.

“You know butterflies,” I stated with a lopsided smile. The man beside me glanced down from where he had stopped in front of one of my larger canvases to observe.

“I do,” he chuckled, nodding to the portrait in front of us. “I take it you like birds too? And flowers?” He gestured to the mismatched wooden tables around the room that I had hand-painted with tiny flower and bird accents. “I like the native species you’ve snuck throughout the decor. It’s beautiful. Very intentional, yet subtle. You’re incredibly gifted.”

“Thank you,” I swallowed thickly, cursing myself for how emotional I sounded.

I was well aware I craved words of affirmation. It wasn’t like I had people lining up to give them to me, though. Sure, genuine compliments or feedback I received at the bakery gave me little boosts of happiness, but it wasn’t as if they were seeing me. No one had ever noticed my art hidden on the walls, let alone complimented it and enthusiastically shared in my interest.

Cohen glanced down at me, his lips slightly pursing before his gaze swept over my features, and whatever he found there had a small smile gracing his lips before he lightly bumped shoulders with me and walked away.

I stared at the ceiling for a moment and shut my eyes, tamping down the longing that had stirred in my heart. In mere minutes, this stranger had me craving something impossible. Who knew where he was from? And did he love God? And did I even want a relationship? Would he even be interested in me? All of those questions bouncing around in my head had me taking a deep breath, murmuring a soft prayer of surrender before turning to face Cohen. He was just another customer, albeit a handsome and kind one, and I would treat him with the same friendliness and openness I did anyone else . . . at least that’s what I kept trying to tell myself.

“So, I like to play a little game with all of my new patrons.” I clapped my hands together as I turned around and walked behind my counter. This was my element. “I get to ask you three questions. Nothing too personal. After you answer, I’ll make a pastry and beverage based on what I think you’d like, and we’ll see how close I get. You game, stranger?”

“What happens if you get it wrong?” he teased lightly, rubbing his scruffy jaw as if he were thinking it over.

“I wouldn’t know.”