Page 12
I must have hesitated for a beat too long, because the handsome stranger hummed, holding up a finger before he reached into his back pocket and pulled out a worn leather bifold. He flipped it open and held it up for me to see. My suspicion ebbed at the gesture, and while I still held my rolling pin, I hesitantly stepped forward and took a look at his ID.
That was him all right. Maybe a few years younger, but it was him. Cohen Taylor. Same handsome features, and same dimple shown off with a ghost of a smile. There was a little bit of satisfaction too that came with the little ‘VETERAN’ in the bottom left corner. I knew it.
I slowly nodded as I stepped back, setting the rolling pin on the counter.
Cohen seemed genuine, and nothing in his body language looked threatening. And I had been telling Bruno to get his tires replaced for months. It seemed plausible.
“Bruno’s okay?”
“Bruno’s okay,” he repeated. “He’s dropping off groceries and will meet me at Lettie’s in half an hour. You are more than welcome to join me so you can see for yourself.”
Maybe I would, if only to get to know this handsome stranger a little more.
“And you’re not a serial killer?” I pressed.
Cohen cleared his throat, his lips pressing tightly together.
“Would I tell you if I was?”
“No, but humor me.”
“No, Winifred. I’m not a serial killer,” he chuckled, shifting the bags of flour a bit as he spoke.
Heat crept up the back of my neck when I remembered the flour. I had kept the poor man standing in my store holding the bags while I worked through my little freak-out.
Where were my manners?
Probably in the back where I left them right next to my common sense.
“I’m so sorry, you can set those right back here in the kitchen,” I said quickly, gesturing for him to follow me as I walked down the hallway and pointed to the pallet nestled in the corner of my kitchen. “Thank you so much.” I watched as he set them down with practiced ease and straightened up. Before I knew what I was doing, I had thrust my hand out in front of me for a handshake.
Why? Why did I do that?
Embarrassment washed over me at the awkward gesture, but it would be worse if I backtracked. Cohen simply eyed it and grinned, dusting his palm off on his jeans before taking my hand in his own in a firm yet strikingly gentle shake.
I nearly shuddered at the contact.
His fingers enveloped my hand so nicely, and I didn’t miss the little sweep his thumb did over my knuckles as he did so.
“I’m sorry. I’m typically more welcoming than this, I swear,” I said nervously, quickly clearing my throat to banish the little quiver there. “I’m Winifred, though you already knew that.”
He squeezed my hand lightly before letting go, his grin transforming into a full-blown smile. The corners of his eyes crinkled, and yep, that was for sure a dimple under his scruff.
“No need to apologize,” he waved me off. “You were worried about your friend, and rightfully skeptical of a stranger coming into your store.”
“Well, justified or not, after I unload this flour, I’d love to grab you a pastry and a drink on the house.”
“That would be great,” he said genuinely, though his gaze caught on the workbench behind me. “But how about I go grab the bags and you finish up whatever you were working on there. I’d hate for a perfectly good pastry to go to waste over a serial killer scare.”
“Oh, you don’t have to do that,” I said reflexively. “I can do it.”
Strong, independent woman and all that jazz. I could carry flour—in fact, I regularly did. Cohen simply shook his head though, and tipped his baseball cap up slightly, as if to look at me better.
“I’m sure you are more than capable, Winifred,” he said lightly. “I’m here, though, and more than happy to take care of it. My mama would have my hide if I didn’t flex a bit of the chivalry she worked so hard to drill into me.”
I tried to muster a protest, but each one died on my lips. Based on the firm set of his jaw, he wasn’t budging on this.
Attraction and anxiety warred within me. Why was I like this? People asked things of me every day, and I bent over backwards to accommodate them. Heaven forbid someone actually offers to help me. It immediately made me feel uncomfortable. I was the one who helped others—not the other way around.