AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Thorne Mountain

Page 127

by Hannah Shield

“And he’s detail-oriented,” Everly went on. “Possibly someone who works with his hands. It’s actually quite difficult to make a murder look like an accident, but he’s managed it at least a few times.”

“And this is definitely a man?” I asked. Sure as fuck sounded like a man, but police weren’t supposed to assume things, right?

“We believe so. The vast majority of serial killers are men, but it also fits the profile.” Everly focused on Delaney again. “If the White Knight killed Freddy Mercer, your father would become the earliest known victim of the killer. Maybe even his first. Which would probably make the corresponding female victim you.”

My stomach leapt all the way into my throat.

I’d made that connection myself, but hearing it so starkly from my sister made it too real. My skin crawled with the need to do something. But all I could do at this moment was rub circles into Delaney’s back.

“I need you to think back to the days and months after your father died in the meth lab explosion,” Everly said. “Did you receive an anonymous handwritten note? Probably left on a door or window where you would find it.”

“A note? I don’t think so. Why?”

A brief hesitation. “Again, this is extremely confidential. We’ve held back a key detail that links two of the killings. Two female victims received handwritten cards saying, You’re safe now, after the killer targeted their abusers. Police found the cards in the dead women’s belongings.”

You’re safe now? Meanwhile, this sick killer was watching them and would eventually murder them too. That was seriously fucked. The more we learned about this guy, the worse it got.

“Did Tisha Pinsky get a card like that?” Delaney asked.

“Yes. Same with the sister of the skinhead. It’s certainly possible the teacher with the abusive father received a similar card as well, but either threw it away or lost it. Do you remember receiving anything at all like that?”

Everly and I both stared at Delaney as she thought.

“Not a card. But…there was a bouquet of flowers. Red daisies. Someone left them for me, I don’t know who, but it was months and months after my dad died. Could that fit the pattern?”

Everly’s face scrunched up. “I don’t believe so. I’ll double-check with the other sheriffs. I’ve been in contact with Sheriff Douglas in Hart County, and he’s great about sharing info. But as far as I know, there hasn’t been anything about flowers.”

Delaney exhaled, and the band around my chest loosened.

“I guess that’s good,” Delaney said. “And also, nothing happened to me. Maybe my dad wasn’t a victim at all. Whatever Ella suspected, she must’ve decided she was wrong. That’s why she didn’t tell anyone.”

I sure as hell hoped that was the case.

But all my protective instincts were still on high alert as Everly grabbed her plate and excused herself. “Gonna grab a slice of Sage’s blackberry-thyme pie and visit with my nieces and nephews. And Keller?” She pointed at me. “Next time, you owe me chocolate.”

“Yeah, yeah. I’ll remember.”

“Thank you, Ev,” Delaney said. “I really appreciate the info. And the risk you’re taking by sharing it with us.”

After Everly was gone, I straddled the picnic bench to face my wife. “How you doing, Firefly? That was a lot.”

“It was. But I’m okay.” She scooted closer. “Feels good to know I’m here with you.”

And that meant everything to me. I kissed her forehead. “I said I’d take care of you. Meant it. Anybody who intends to mess with you has to go through me.”

Then something pricked at my mind.

“I remember those flowers,” I said. “The red ones. You don’t have any theory about who could’ve sent them?”

It had been the day we’d broken up. Same day some anonymous snitch—maybe my brother Royce—texted Delaney and told her to come see what I was doing at the lake.

Delaney leaned into me. “No idea. When I got home that night, the flowers were on the stairs outside Ella’s apartment. Mangled. Some animal must’ve gotten them out of the trash and left them there. A dog or raccoon, maybe.”

Which sounded really weird. But any weirder than the rest of this?

One thing was certain. My daughter’s hobby of investigating the White Knight Killer was over, as of today. She was not going to like hearing it.

CHAPTER THIRTY-NINE