Page 126
I put my hand on Delaney’s thigh. She’d hardly taken two bites of food. But she was quick to answer Everly’s question. “Ella had a picture of my childhood home mixed in with her papers about the White Knight Killer.”
She told Everly about the old newspaper photo in Josie’s binder, and how Ella hadn’t explained her theory to anyone.
“Could it be a coincidence?” Everly asked. “I’m sure Ella had other papers about you. Given how close you two were.”
“But when Josie asked about it, Ella got really sensitive. Ella said she’d thought the photo was related to the killer, but she’d been wrong. Tried to take the photo away. Then Josie found it again later. JoJo doesn’t know it has anything to do with me.”
“It could match the pattern of the killer,” I pointed out. “A death made to look like an accident. You just admitted the investigation wasn’t thorough enough to know if foul play was involved. The killer could’ve tampered with the equipment in the meth lab. Probably wouldn’t have been hard to set up the explosion.”
Everly took a couple of bites of food, seeming to think.
“What I’m about to tell you doesn’t leave this table.”
I looked to Delaney. She nodded, and I did as well. “Sure. We’ll keep it quiet.”
“No, Keller. I’m dead serious. This is highly confidential. If you share any of this with a single person, it could compromise the investigation.”
“Okay. Message received. So are you saying there really is a White Knight Killer? From what we’ve heard, law enforcement hasn’t confirmed or denied. It’s mainly just online rumors so far.”
Everly pushed her plate back with a sigh. “It took years for the pattern to emerge. When suspicions arose, local sheriffs and chiefs of police in the region shared their information. That’s crucial in a case like this, since criminals don’t care about jurisdiction. So yes, we do believe there’s an active serial killer, and the name White Knight is as good as any.”
Delaney laced my fingers with hers.
“I can’t share any confidential documents or confirm anything in writing, but I’ll tell you what I know.”
Everly described three sets of victims they’d tied to the White Knight Killer. The stories matched the articles in Josie’s file.
“The first known victim, twelve years ago, was a skinhead. Part of a neo-Nazi group. He overdosed, and it was ruled accidental. But about six months later, his sister was found dead of carbon monoxide poisoning. Again, ruled accidental at first. But there were suspicions at the time that her wood stove had been tampered with. The investigators couldn’t rule out foul play, but they had no suspects. Especially since her violent brother was dead, and she’d been living a much happier, safer life afterward.”
“Could a member of her brother’s gang have targeted her?” I asked.
“No evidence whatsoever the gang members knew where she was, or had any interest in her. But you can see why the pattern wasn’t clear yet. Years went by. We believe the killer struck again about six years ago down in Durango. Set up a fire to kill a handyman known as a domestic abuser, then strangled the man’s daughter—a teacher—several months later.”
Delaney shivered. “Strangled her. That was an escalation, right?”
“Very much so.”
“He did the same to Tisha Pinsky. The woman whose body was found in Hart County.”
“Yes.” Everly folded her hands on the table. “The killings of the men tend to be well-planned. Either it looks like an accident, or the guy just disappears. The killer never leaves usable forensic evidence behind. He’s meticulous and highly organized. But the killings of the women show more…emotion. He’s angrier, less organized. With the most recent female victims, he made no effort to make it appear an accident. The strangulations are far more personal and violent.”
“He’s punishing them,” Delaney whispered, covering her mouth.
I massaged the back of her neck. “But why?”
“For not being perfect,” Everly supplied. “For some imagined flaw. Maybe they aren’t grateful enough.”
“Does that mean he knows the victims personally?” I asked.
Everly shook her head. “Doubtful. We haven’t found any ties between the sets of victims, apart from living in Colorado. This killer is the type who likes to watch from afar. Judging. Deciding who deserves to live or die.”
I pushed out a breath. “Fucking hell.”
And my daughter was obsessed with investigating this sicko. She’d even talked Delaney into taking her to one of the actual crime scenes. Nope. I had to put an end to that. As soon as possible.
“I’ve put together a rough profile from what we know,” Everly said. “He’s someone who can hide in plain sight. He has a job that allows him to travel without suspicion, at least periodically. The pairs of killings have sometimes been years apart, so he chooses his victims very carefully.”
A couple years ago, as a deputy, Everly had attended a training for state law enforcement officers at Quantico to learn from the FBI. Sounded like she’d picked up some useful skills.