Page 12
His moans had transformed to whimpers, but Jack didn’t even pause. Theo tried to hold onto his release for as long as he could, but Jack, as always, could read his mind and knew how to make him lose the battle.
Jack stroked him faster, rubbing his palm over the head of his leaking cock. Theo’s toes curled and shivers ran through his body, his release coming out in slow, steady spurts.
He let out a heavy breath and waited for the guilt to return. It didn’t. Instead, Theo stepped out of the shower and dried himself off. There was something different in the air, and it had something to do with the fact that he’d had a sexy daydream in the shower about his ex boyfriend who he wasn’t quite sure was still married, and he wasn’t ashamed.
As he threw on the borrowed clothes, he stared at himself in the full length mirror again. Somehow, he’d transformed into someone entirely different during his shower. Someone who knew what he wanted for the first time in his life…even if it was something that terrified him.
He wasn’t sure how he was going to do it or what he was going to say, but he promised himself that coming back to Lake Falls would be different.
And he had to start with what was right in front of him: Jack Claus.
Chapter 6
By the time Theo was back downstairs, he was back in a state of reality. He sat carefully in one of the barstools and watched Jack rifle through the kitchen cabinets. He’d changed into his own set of pajamas, and his hair was tied up in a messy hair bun that flopped on the side of his head.
“I was thinking about making some tea,” he explained. “Is the county peach tea still your favorite?”
Theo nodded silently. He knew he was staring intensely, but he couldn’t help it. He was an entirely different person now and he wanted so badly for Jack to notice the difference between the version of him that had needed a rescue and the version of him that finally felt ready for him.
He knew the optics weren’t great. Jacking off to his ex who was (maybe) married and sniffing his underwear was probably high on the list of things you just didn’t do. Especially when it involved having a hallucinated version of the ex do the jacking off.
“Enjoy the shower?” Jack flipped the electric kettle on and turned to look at Theo. Their eyes met and a soft smile spread across his face. He studied Theo, his smile transforming into a sheepish grin. “I’m glad the clothes fit.”
The clothes did not fit, but they hung off his shoulders fashionably, so he wasn’t uncomfortable.
“Jack.” Theo tried to be careful with his name. He wanted to treat Jack as delicately as he deserved. He watched as Jack dipped the tea bag into the freshly boiled water.
“Theo?” He raised one eyebrow.
“When are you going to ask me why I’m here?” Theo asked.
Jack sighed. “I don’t get you, Theo. I sent all those letters and you never replied. You came to my parents’ funeral and you didn’t stay. Now you want me to ask you why? After I’ve spent twenty years thinking about it?”
Theo let the silence linger as he watched Jack make the tea. Then he slid the cup and a plate of warm toast towards Theo. Previously smiling, his expression now was guarded and he refused to meet Theo’s eyes. Theo, on the other hand, was determined to have this conversation. This time, he was determined to answer honestly.
Theo was too nervous to sit, so he stayed standing. Jack, on the other hand, sat in one of the bar stools and waited for Theo to say more.
Theo focused on the crimson tip of Jack’s nose.
He took a sip of his tea. It was delicious.
“You didn’t decorate this year.”
“Theo.” Jack’s voice was firm. “You’re stalling…aren’t you?”
The question was heavy between them.
“I’m sorry.” The weight of the words was different from any other apology he’d given that day. He’d opened the door now, and he didn’t want to give himself the opportunity to run away from what he’d done or the hurt he’d caused.
“I did read your letters,” Theo confessed. “I was scared, so I never responded. I think…when we were younger and in love, I was so wrapped up in everything I wanted to do, and to be, and I knew you didn’t want the same things. You didn’t want to live in a big city with glitz and glamour and you didn’t want to live a life where you had to pretend to be someone you weren’t just to make money and rub shoulders with people who were famous. You wanted something more real, and I wasn’t ready for that. I wasn’t ready, and instead of being honest, I ran.”
Jack’s lips were a thin line, but his gaze held steady as he waited for Theo to continue.
“You know, when I first left Vermont, I thought I had it all figured out. I didn’t choose the easy path of marrying the guy I loved and living in my hometown. I was somewhere new and I was following my dreams. I thought I could go there for a few years, figure it out, then come home and convince you to come, too. Or something.”
“Or something.” Jack repeated..
Theo’s response was a wry smile. He’d been so wrong, he saw that now. “College was fine. I didn’t love it, but I also wasn’t as miserable as I’d be in the future. I came home for a few summers during that time, and every summer I was home, I was avoiding you, and I think you were avoiding me too with all your summer-long homestead projects.” At the confused look on Jack’s face, Theo added, “Your mom told my mom who told me. Anyway, I know I could have sent you letters. I thought about it every day, but it didn’t seem fair, and I didn’t know what to say. ‘I’m sorry I dumped you, my life really sucks right now and I miss you, please take me back?’ It felt too pathetic.”