AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

A Reindeer Ex for Christmas

Page 11

by Noelle Drake

He’d taken their sweet moments for granted. The ones where they’d been completely alone in the house, Theo’s legs tangled beneath Jack’s bedsheets, their hands exploring each other’s bodies.

Or the Christmas where he’d traced every inch of Jack’s body with his tongue…

…now he was feeling really regretful.

The mixture of his misery and lust made Theo rock hard and he didn’t want the feeling to end. In some sick and twisted way, he was atoning for the sins he’d committed against Jack. It had been a long time since he’d had the opportunity for an itch to be perfectly scratched, and he welcomed the feeling.

Theo let his soapy fingers crawl up his wet body. His fingers grazed over his nipples cautiously, and he let out a soft exhale in response. Every touch was like electricity through his body, and he let himself enjoy it.

By the time his hands reached the flattened wet curls of his pubic hair, he was more concerned with generating memories of the past than being quiet in the present. In his mind, he saw every version of Jack that he could have loved. Every kiss they could have shared. Every meal, every laugh, every thought. He could feel the pain of the years wasted, and he didn’t want to simmer in it any longer.

He’d made a promise to himself; a promise that he was no longer going to run from the things he wanted.

The Jack of the real world was probably lost to him, but that didn’t mean he had to exist in reality alone. He’d seen him now. He knew that no matter what had happened then, Jack had bounced back, and he owed him an explanation.

But that would come later.

Now, he was going to let the soap and water wash his pain away.

He was going to turn his pain into pleasure.

In the real world, Jack was probably downstairs in the living room relaxing, thinking about what the hell he was doing lending a helping hand and a warm bed to his ex-boyfriend. The fake-world shower version of Jack was entirely different from the man he didn’t know anymore.

As he stood under the shower jets, Theo’ s mind was only on Jack. Jack, with soft green eyes that sparkled with flecks of gold. Jack, with shiny auburn hair that flowed in the wind like birds on a summer morning. Jack, with soft pink lips that held a promise of warmth and tenderness.

What was it that had always made Jack so irresistible?

Theo knew the answer.

It was the way he laughed when he held his hand tight in the rain, the two of them running for shelter. It was the way he always wanted to argue who was more likely to win Brooke Shields’ heart (the answer was obviously Jack). It was the way whenever they baked, Jack did all the work because Theo burnt the brownies that one time, and he always saved a massive spoonful of batter for Theo.

Theo had always needed Jack, and he’d always been so afraid to admit it. Everything about Jack, from his thick dark lashes to his strong, confident voice…Theo needed all of him.

He closed his eyes, letting his mind take over entirely until reality no longer mattered.

He could feel Jack now, standing behind him in the shower, dwarfing him with his full form. The difference in their bodies had always excited him, the way he was always protected by Jack’s shadow.

Jack pressed his chest against Theo’s back, his hard nipples grazing him softly as he reached around with one hand to stroke Theo’s desperate cock.

Jack squeezed him, eliciting a groan from deep within Theo’s throat. He should have cared about being heard, but he didn’t. A dark part of him wished that Jack had heard the sound. He wanted to be thought about the same way.

He wanted to be wanted again.

Behind him, dream Jack’s chest shifted with every pump, his voice syrupy as he said, “I haven’t been with you like this in so long…I’ve missed it.”

Theo said nothing until Jack’s stiff cock hardened against him. It was exactly like he’d remembered it, the thickness covered by a dense layer of fur. Theo wanted so badly for this to be real; for Jack to be here with him, the two of them reconnecting in a familiar way with their new selves.

“J-Jack.” Theo was barely able to let the sound out.

Jack was quiet. All Theo felt was his hands on his body and his release coming too fast. He wanted things to keep going.

How long had he been in the shower? Actually, he didn’t care.

His breaths were ragged and his chest rose and fell with effort. Jack dragged his fist up and down Theo’s cock, squeezing and twisting the tip of his cock as he worked on him. The water was so hot. His skin felt like it was peeling away, but he didn’t care.

He rested his forehead against the cool shower tile and wrapped his hand over Jack’s. Looking down, he could see his tanned hand over Jack’s pale one, the two of them in perfect rhythm as Theo thrusted into their hands with all the strength he could muster.

“Jack,” Theo whined. “I’m so close.”