AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

This Silver Bell

Page 24

by Kate Breitfeller

My eyebrows bunch. “Oops, sorry. I forgot. That was the other thing in the diary. She was planning on taking the jewels and running away.”

Leo gapes at me. “That’s a pretty important part of the story.”

I wince. “Sorry. I forgot you haven’t read the diary. There are some entries about her wanting to get away and needing to fund her trip.”

“Then there’s no mystery. She ran.” He crosses his arms across his chest, looking disappointed.

“But no one ever recovered them, and no one ever tried to sell them in Scotland or England. I guess some of the pieces were memorable.”

Leo frowns. “If they were that valuable, why weren’t they in a bank?”

“They were,” I say gleefully, because frankly I’m so impressed by Annabelle for this part of the story. “Annabelle convinced her father that she wanted to wear one of the pieces at the ball, so they were all brought for her to choose.”

Leo looks past my shoulder clearly thinking. “She could have said that so they moved the jewels, knowing she was planning on making an escape.”

“Yes.” I clap my hands with excitement. “She doesn’t say it explicitly in the diary, but it’s obviously part of her plan.”

“Then she had something of value on her.”

I shake my head, barely able to contain my smile. “Her father wouldn’t let her wear them. At the last minute, he changed his mind and only allowed her to wear the silver brooch, but it wasn’t worth enough to hide her forever.” I hold up a finger. “But it wasn’t on her dress when they found it either, so maybe she did take it.”

Leo shakes his head. “She must have come back for the jewels during the party or told the boyfriend how to get in.”

“She couldn’t have,” I point out. “Not after the party started. The one time she left the party, Edmund followed after her, that was when they had the fight. Apparently, Edmund had a reputation for a violent temper.”

Leo’s brow furrows. “What’s the other twist?”

“What?”

“You said there were more.”

“Right. The valet. It was later discovered that he’d been killed in an ‘accident’ in Edinburgh only a few weeks after the ball. There was no sign of Annabelle or that he’d ever had the jewels. After that, society turned on Edmund. It made for good gossip. Did Edmund do something to Annabelle, and the valet knew? Or had Annabelle run off with the valet but for some reason couldn’t get the jewels, and after he died, she was too ashamed to resurface?”

Leo studies me for a minute. “Okay, Nancy Drew, what’s your theory?”

I wiggle in my seat, thrilled to share my ideas. I’ve already bored Lily to death with my theories, and surprisingly, no one on the movie seems to care that much.

“I think she ran off with her lover, who was not the valet, because of the way she described him. She talked a lot about going for long walks and trying to be out of the castle as much as possible. That’s where they would meet up. Though in the diary, she’s very vague about the details. If he was a valet, he wouldn’t be able to leave the house that often.

“That night Annabelle could have hidden the jewels somewhere in the castle, but, for whatever reason, couldn’t come back for them. Maybe because of the search. So, she and the lover lived a modest but happy life somewhere far away.”

His smile softens. “Ever the romantic.”

He’s right. I am a romantic. And look where it’s got me. Ignoring the sting at the back of my throat, I continue.

“The current, most popular theory, which the movie is written around, suggests Edmund found out about the other man and killed her in a fit of rage. Then he either bullied or paid off the valet—remember Edmund’s missing cash—to dispose of her body that night.” I frown. “That theory doesn’t explain what happened to the jewels though.”

“Okay, so either Edmund killed her, or she left with the valet, or⁠—”

“Or she ran on her own and let everybody assume the rest.”

“Are you planning on solving it while you’re here? Locating the missing jewels?” he teases.

I arch my brow. “You think I couldn’t.”

“I would never bet against you. You’re a force of nature.” Something flickers in his eyes, but it’s gone again too quickly to identify it.

“Damn straight.” I grin widely at him.