Page 23
“I’m not just a pretty face.” Leo pretends to dust off his shoulder.
“But it was when the diary was discovered behind a wardrobe a couple of years ago, when they were repairing the castle after a leak in the roof, that the interest really took off,” I add.
“What was in the diary that suddenly made this movie worthy?”
I lean forward. “Because the diary revealed that Annabelle was in love with someone else. Someone unsuitable.”
He arches a brow clearly trying not to laugh. “Unsuitable?”
My lips twitch despite myself. “Her word not mine. Could have been a servant, or somebody who came up with one of the hunting parties. Whoever he was, he’s definitely around three weeks before Christmas when Edmund returns with a betrothal agreement her father had already signed.”
“What happened?”
“Nobody knows. That’s the mystery. Edmund and her father threw this massive, fancy Christmas ball to announce their engagement. They invited all the who’s who of society from Edinburgh to London because Edmund wanted everyone to know about his new noble wife. But when it’s time to announce the betrothal, Annabelle is nowhere to be found.
“Her father assumed she bolted. But then during the yelling and accusations, a maid comes forward and says she witnessed Edmund and Annabelle fighting earlier in the night. When he saw he had an audience, he screamed at the maid to get out. Then Edmund returned to the ballroom with scratches down his face and told anyone who asked that he had fallen. Seemed suspicious once the guests realized his fiancée was missing.”
“Just a little,” Leo drawls.
“Her father and their limited staff tore the castle apart. But they found nothing that pointed either way. Every dress she owned was still hanging in her room. So, knowing that Annabelle was a young woman with no close friends or funds, everyone assumed Edmund did something to her.” I pause. “Early the next morning one of the ghillies, the guys who lead the hunt, found the gown she’d been wearing out on the hill. Torn.”
Leo leans forward, his interest caught. “Just the dress?”
“Just the dress. No body. No Annabelle.”
He looks at me for a moment. “What about her jewelry?”
“She was only wearing a silver bell-shaped brooch that night. Edmund hadn’t given her a ring yet.”
His gaze drops to the brooch pinned to my sweater, and my cheeks flush a little.
“I guess it’s silly, but it felt meant to be when I saw it in London. However, Annabelle’s had a giant seed pearl underneath for the clapper, and the ribbons above the bell were studded with diamonds.”
He blows out a low whistle. “Sounds expensive. Was it still on the dress?”
I shake my head. “It was never found.”
Leo looks thoughtful for a moment. “What about the boyfriend? Why didn’t they look at him?”
“Because,” I lightly drum a beat on the table for emphasis while Leo grins at me. “Nobody knew about him. No one even knew another man existed for over 100 years.” I push out my lips. “Though they considered she may have had help, because Edmund Morgenstern’s valet vanished the same night, and he’d stolen all of Edmund’s cash on hand.”
Leo’s brows meet between his eyes. “Where’s the mystery? Sounds like the valet was the mystery man and they ran off together.”
I huff out a breath. “Ye of little faith. I’m not done yet. There are a couple more twists.”
Blue eyes sparkle at me. “You really love this, don’t you?”
“How can you not? It’s got everything. Drama, betrayal, romance, mystery!”
Leo’s shoulders shake as he holds in his laughter, and I’m briefly distracted by his wide smile—the way it softens the sharp angles of his face, the faint crease at the corner of those bright blue eyes. My gaze dips lower still, tracing the strong column of his throat before I force it back up.
“What are these twists?”
Right, telling a story, not ogling him.
“Apparently late the next day, her father realizes all the jewels are gone. The night Annabelle disappeared, he opened the safe to check, and the boxes were all there. But the idiot never opened them. Annabelle took the jewels that night.”
“You don’t know that for sure.”