AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Falling for the Holidays

Page 58

by Erin Hawkins

I try very hard not to stare at his package but fail instantly. There is simply too much happening in that region.

“You’re really committed to the theme,” I say, aiming for dry and landing somewhere closer to breathless.

He shrugs, easy and smug. “Can’t half-arse a Christmas movie couples’ theme party. Besides,” his eyes flick over me, warm, “if I’m your plus-one, I’m giving you my A-game.”

My heart does a ridiculous little flip.

“A-game with…that?” I wave a hand vaguely at the whole yellow-tights situation.

His mouth curves. “So, you were looking.”

“You poured all that into spandex and then expected me not to look?”

He laughs, low and delighted. “You keep staring like that and I’m going to start charging admission, love.”

If that’s the show I’m getting, I’d buy a million tickets.

Before I can fire back, Oliver barrels in from the hallway, his hands now a lighter shade of pink. He skids to a stop, eyes going huge. “WHOA.”

My soul leaves my body, but not before I pray he doesn’t say what I’m afraid he’s about to say.

“That’s a huge—” Oliver starts, pointing.

Time slows.

Please don’t say bulge. Please don’t say package. Please don’t say⁠—

“—bottle of maple syrup,” he finishes, awestruck. “Can we put it on everything like Buddy does?”

I slap a hand over my mouth to smother a hysterical laugh, while Beck grins, lifting the jar.

“It’s one of the four main food groups. Candy, candy canes, candy corn, and syrup.” He waves the jar for emphasis.

Maddie wrangles Oliver into the living room, while he states that they have to watch Elf now while they play board games.

I’m still blinking at Beck…the syrup, the green jacket, but mostly the tights, when he holds out a garment bag. “Your turn, love.”

“My…what is that?” My voice comes out strange and thin.

“Your Jovie costume.” He thrusts it gently into my hands. “Go on. Open it.”

With trembling fingers, I unzip the bag—and gasp.

Inside is the pink-and-red elf dress from the end of the Elf movie. Jovie’s North Pole outfit. The soft pink dress with the red ribbon belt and white faux-fur trim. The cute little red shoes. The pointy pink hat with red ribbon. And instead of full tights, there’s a pair of red thigh-high socks. Those aren’t movie accurate, but they’re a lot sexier.

My throat gets tight. “You got this for me?”

He shrugs, but it’s the casual kind that hides something warmer. “Saw it online and thought of you. I guessed your size.” Then with a twitch of his lips adds, “Okay, I might’ve had Juniper double-check.”

“Beck,” I whisper, because I genuinely might cry. “You can’t just bring me a whole costume.”

“Why not?” He steps closer, studying my face with that infuriatingly gentle expression. “We can’t win best Christmas movie couple if we’re not a matched set.”

Something hot and sharp blooms beneath my ribs. “Yeah, but you didn’t have to do that.”

“I know,” he says, softer now. “I wanted to.”

I swallow hard and clutch the hanger tighter. “I—I’ll go change.”