AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Falling for the Holidays

Page 57

by Erin Hawkins

His reply comes fast.

Beck

It means don’t pick an outfit. I’m bringing yours.

My eyebrows jump so high they nearly leave my forehead. My hands suddenly feel clumsy. He’s bringing an outfit? For me? To a couples’ theme party? I don’t know if I should be grateful or panic.

Please tell me this isn’t a sex thing. There will be other people there.

He pauses before answering.

Beck

Not a sex thing. Though you’ll look hot and I’ll be dying to fuck you. Just trust me.

My heart does a weird, panicked flutter. Beck asking me to trust him is the kind of thing that should make me dig in my heels. Instead, it sends a hot little shiver down my spine.

Why do I feel like this is dangerous?

Beck

Because you like to control everything. See you in ten.

I stare at my phone, then over at the batch of cookies I’m preparing for the party, which suddenly seems like the least chaotic part of my night.

When the first knock comes, I’m elbow-deep in icing and trying to keep Oliver from “taste-testing” every third cookie on the cooling rack. Adult-only party logistics are always a little intense, but thankfully Maddie from down the street agreed to babysit. She’s nineteen, calm, and thinks Oliver is “hilarious,” which means she has no idea what she’s in for.

Oliver sprints to the front door before I can even yell, “Walk!” His socks slide on the hardwood, and he pinwheels his arms but somehow doesn’t wipe out.

“Maddie’s here!” he calls, yanking the door open.

“Hey, dude,” I hear her say, amused. “You ready for game night?”

“Yup,” he says, before pointing to the teetering stack of board games he’s arranged in the living room.

“Can’t wait,” she laughs. “Go wash your hands, though. They’re…pink?”

“Food coloring,” he says.

I smile to myself as I wipe a streak of icing off my hand. When Oliver disappears down the hall, I step out to the entry, thank Maddie again, show her what’s for dinner, then run through the “no YouTube rabbit holes” rule, before ducking back into the kitchen.

I’m placing the last of the cookies into the tin when the second knock comes.

When I open the door, I almost forget how to stand upright.

It’s Beck, standing on my porch in full Buddy the Elf costume: green coat, cone-shaped green hat with yellow hatband and red feather, yellow tights, and black curly-toe shoes. In one hand, he’s holding a jar of maple syrup. My eyes scan over him, doing a double take.

Because the tights…oh god, the tights.

They’re snug. Alarmingly so. Hugging every line of his long, muscular legs and absolutely not leaving much to the imagination. I never realized that yellow was such an informative color.

He beams at me. “Smiling’s my favorite.”

My brain fizzles like pop rocks on a tongue.

“Beck,” I finally manage. “What are you wearing?”

“Authentic character attire,” he says, breezing past me into the entryway like this is a perfectly normal Saturday night. He lifts the syrup. “With props.”