Page 97
“Morning,” she says, eyes darting away again.
Shit.
This isn’t good. We’ve got one foot in awkward territory, and I refuse to let that happen. This is one fear I could never conquer when contemplating crossing this line with her.
I’d rather never touch her again than let things get weird between us.
“Hey.” I keep my tone casual, even as my heart thunders from the sprint and surprise. “How’d you sleep?”
She looks up, surprised, and something settles in her expression.
I exhale.
“I think Daryll and Pete have one of those fancy designer mattresses.” She edges closer to the island. “After two weeks in Brie’s basement, my back thanks them.”
I huff a laugh. “I think anything would beat the pull-out from hell.” Pouring boiling water into the glass funnel, I ask, “Coffee?”
“God, yes.”
Like that, we’re Charlie and Hunter again.
I shoot her a crooked smile. “I think this hipster shit takes a few minutes.”
She nods, pressing her lips together, glancing around the apartment. Her cheeks go a little pink when she eyes the sofa. Is she looking for physical evidence, or just reliving it?
“How was the couch?” she asks, voice cracking a little.
I pretend not to hear. “Fine. I was too wiped for it to matter.”
My response is matter-of-fact—what I would have said before. Our every interaction might be riddled with subtext, but I want her to feel comfortable. Like it’s still us.
We sure as fuck can’t go back to the way things were, but right now, I’m more concerned with spooking her.
When she doesn’t answer, I look up from the coffee to find her watching me.
Her brows are raised in outrage. Fuck.
“You—” Her mouth drops open, a humorless laugh spilling out. “Wells, are you going to pretend like last night didn’t happen?”
“What?” The pour-over rattles in my hand, clanging against the counter. Releasing it, I step back. “Shit. No, but, uh—you want to talk about it?”
“Yeah, I want to talk about it.” She squints, like I’ve told a joke that didn’t land. “I wouldn’t file this big, intimate thing with my best friend under ‘we’ll circle back never.’”
I cough to cover my surprise. Is that what it was to her? Big? Intimate?
This is good. Shocking, but good.
“Well, uh—” I clear my throat. “We never usually talk about this stuff.”
She stares like I’m the biggest moron known to man. “Because it never involved us before.” Her eyes narrow, and I really fucking hate that tea kettle for waking her up. “Don’t tell me you’re one of those guys who hooks up with a girl, then pretends it never happened.”
“Seriously?” I level her a flat look. “You know I’m not.”
“Fine.” She fists her hips. Only she could look so goddamn intimidating in pajama pants. “Then start talking.”
She’s caught me so off guard, I gape. I might know what I want, but I never thought I’d get as far as we did last night, let alone that she’d want to discuss it. She usually cuts and runs.
I’m utterly unprepared for this conversation.