AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

You Feel Like Christmas

Page 96

by Christine Drummond

Before I can say anything, her chin trembles. I made her come, and now she’s about to cry.

“Wells?” My name warbles on her tongue, like the girl who used to show up on my doorstep, hiding from the shouting across the street. My heart cracks wide open, and everything I feel—hope and love and fear and resignation—pours out.

“Shhhh,” I say, gathering her back in my arms. She shifts, turning sideways in my lap. I pull her head against my chest and press my lips to her hair, stroking down her back. “You don’t need to worry about that now. I’ve got you.”

She shudders, sniffling against my chest.

“I’ve always got you.”

Wincing against the morning sun, I give up on Pete’s fancy espresso machine and reach for Daryll’s pour-over. I barely slept, and need caffeine more than oxygen right now.

Filling a kettle, I glance across the brightly lit apartment toward the shut bedroom door.

Nothing. Not a sound.

There’s a small chance she bailed. Vanished like a thief in the night, taking my sanity as her bounty rather than face our actions together.

Coffee. I need coffee.

After Charlie dozed off on my chest, I carried her into the bedroom and tucked her in. I thought about getting her out of her dress, but after what we’d done, it felt like crossing a line. This wasn’t caring for a friend with the flu.

If she wants me to undress her, I need to hear her say it.

After removing her shoes, I took a much-needed shower, washing away the evidence of what we’d done, and borrowed a pair of Pete’s sweats.

Then I lay on the couch and watched the ceiling for hours.

At first, elation and adrenaline kept me awake. I’d finally done it—grown some balls and made a move, and—she’d kissed me back. Met my enthusiasm, blow for blow.

But once my high faded, irrational, all-consuming, middle-of-the-night anxiety crept in.

She’d nearly cried, after. What did that mean?

Did she regret it? Had it been bad?

No. It wasn’t bad. Even my tortured heart couldn’t delude itself that far.

We’d found release so readily, it was like two decades of foreplay had culminated at once. And thank fuck, because if my suit had broken her brain, touching her—tasting her—had annihilated mine. If she hadn’t come so fast, I might have stripped her down and fucked her there on the couch, and then I’d have no question over her regrets.

Fitful sleep finally claimed me around dawn, but it didn’t last.

Now, raking a hand through my hair, I drag myself to the bathroom and turn on the faucet. Minus the horrific hair situation and shadows under my eyes, the guy staring back looks the same as always. It seems impossible, like the magnitude of last night should be etched into my skin.

I’ve barely splashed water on my face when a high-pitched whistle pierces the apartment.

Shit.

I dash, dripping, into the kitchen and snap off the burner. The screech dies and I exhale, burying my face in a clean dishtowel, praying I didn’t wake her.

A door clicks and a throat clears.

My head jerks up.

Charlie stands in the bedroom doorway, wearing gray pajama pants and her NYU sweatshirt.

Even from here, magenta-painted toes tracing circles on the floor, she looks angelic in the morning light.

She studies the hardwoods before peeking up at me.