AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

In The Line Of Fire

Page 43

by Dani Dane

The apartment is quiet as I make my way down the hall, it’s late, and Zoey is already asleep. I can hear her soft breathing and quiet snores faintly through the closed door to their room. The sound does something to me, something that feels both grounding and overwhelming all at once, the idea that they’re here, that this space already holds pieces of them, that they feel safe here with me, that this doesn’t feel temporary anymore, everything about this feels right. When I reach the kitchen, Paige is standing by the stove, drinking tea with her back to me, wearing my old FDNY sweatshirt that I'll probably never get back, as she moves with that familiar rhythm I can’t seem to get enough of. It’s comfortable and unguarded, like she belongs here, and if I’m being brave enough to admit it, it really feels like she does, like they both do. She doesn’t turn to face me, but I can still feel the tension, immediate and undeniable, settling in the space between us. I feel it in the way my chest tightens, in the way I don’t even consider stopping myself as I move closer. There’s no point in holding back now, not when I already know, not when I’ve already chosen, and definitely not when last night made it impossible to pretend this is anything less than exactly what it is.

“Paige,” I say quietly, my voice comes out rougher than I expect, betraying every feeling that I’m done trying to ignore.

She stiffens, enough that I notice, I always notice, as much as she might try to hide it, as much as she might try to keep everything locked down, her body has never been good at lying, not to me. I keep moving closer until I’m standing directly in front of her, close enough to feel her warmth, to smell the faint trace of vanilla in her hair, and it makes my chest tighten. This ache between us isn’t going to go away, if anything, it’s only growing.

“Last night…” I start but the words stall out in my throat, not because I don’t know what it meant, but because I do, because I know exactly how this could be the exact moment that changes everything, and how easily, if I say the wrong thing right now, I could send her running.

She doesn’t turn to face me, her voice coming out low and unsteady, like she’s holding herself together out of sheer force. “Zach… last night wasn’t just a kiss.”

“I know,” I answer gently, shifting even closer to her, our bodies practically touching. “I felt it too.”

“I didn’t mean for that to happen last night,” she admits, her voice faltering. “I just…” She starts to add, then trails off, she might be attempting to push me away, but her body betrays her because she leans in slightly, like she’s drawn to me even as she tries to stay guarded.

My hand lifts before I think better of it, brushing against her arm, light and careful, she stills instantly at the touch, and her breath catches. “It’s okay,” I whisper. “You don’t have to explain it.”

“I’m not trying to explain the kiss, I just…” She tries again, her voice breaking as she tries to push out the words, she swallows hard before she continues. “I need you to understand something because if you don’t understand this, then none of this—” she gestures slightly between us “—will work.” Her words make my chest ache.

I nod because, honestly, I’d agree to anything she said as long as it meant she’d keep looking at me like this. “Then help me understand.”

“I don’t do halfway,” she declares quietly. “I can’t, not with Zoey. If I let you in,” she continues, her voice barely above a whisper, “it’s not just me you’re choosing, it’s her, and if you walk away—” her voice breaks, before she has to force the rest out, “you walk away from her too.”

Every word she says lands like a slow, deliberate cut, but I don’t even flinch.

“I know,” I reply, and I mean it. God, I really mean it. “Paige, I’m not—”

She shakes her head, pulling her arm out of my grip like the contact burns. “You don’t know,” she insists, a little sharper now, her voice betraying her fear. “Because wanting something and being ready for it aren’t the same thing.”

“You’re right,” I tell her. “Wanting you isn’t the same as being ready for you, but don’t confuse your fear with the truth. Don’t tell me I’ll leave when you haven’t even given me the chance to stay.”

She shakes her head as her tears finally begin spilling over. “You don’t understand what it’s like to look at your kid and explain why someone didn’t give a damn enough to stay.”

My jaw tightens at the thought of everything that’s happened to this woman in her young life. “No,” I assert quietly. “But I do know what it’s like to spend years avoiding anything that could matter enough to hurt me.” That makes her pause, her gaze shifting to mine. “I kept everything, everyone at a distance,” I continue, “because it felt safer not to care than to risk losing something that mattered.” I reach out to touch her, my movements slower this time, as I gently brush my fingers against her arm. “But you matter, both of you,” I continue, “and I'd never—” My voice falters, and I have to push down the lump in my throat before I can keep going. “I'd never take that lightly. I’m not asking you to hand me her heart,” I go on. “Or yours right now. I’m asking you to let me show you who I can be when things stop being easy.” She stares at me like she wants to believe me, like believing me might be her undoing. “I’m right here, and I’m not going anywhere,” I declare.

“That’s easy for you to say now,” she whispers, her voice fragile and raw, “but meaning it is something else entirely.”

“I know,” I tell her, not backing down from her challenge. “And I know you don’t believe me yet, so watch me, let me show you that I can be the man who stays, the man you deserve.”

The silence stretches between us, thick and heavy. Paige presses a hand to her chest like it hurts to breathe, pressing her lips together tightly as she fights tears. “I can’t afford to be wrong about this, about you.”

“I know.” My voice breaks. “But pushing me away doesn’t guarantee you’ll be right either, it only guarantees you’ll never know if this could’ve been something different. That this,” I gesture slightly between us like she did before, “will be something different.” Her eyes search mine, desperate to find the lie, to find a crack but she doesn’t find one. “I’m already attached,” I admit. “To her, to you. I didn’t plan on it, and yeah, maybe it happened faster than it should’ve, but that doesn’t make it any less true,” I maintain. “I’m not asking for a place in her life or yours that you aren’t ready to give me yet. I’m only asking you not to shut the door on this because you’re afraid of what might happen if you actually let me in.”

My heart aches as I look at her, this woman I’m already way too deep with. “I choose you,” I declare, my voice betraying every emotion I’m feeling despite trying to keep myself together. “Not only when it’s easy, not only when it’s quiet, I’m choosing the mess, the fear, and the uncertainty. All of it. I’m choosing you, Paige, you and Zoey, and if you can really look at me and still tell me to leave after I’ve said this, I will, but please don’t make that decision without giving me a chance first.”

A tear slips down her cheek and I reach up, stopping short of touching her, giving her one last chance to still turn away. “Let me fight for you, for her,” I whisper. “Let me prove it to you, let me love you the only way I know how, honestly.” Her breath catches, but I can see the way she’s still holding herself back. “I’m here,” I say, my voice even lower now. “Please.” The words are a desperate plea on my lips. “Please let me stay in your lives. I’m not here to take anything from you,” I continue softly. “I’m here because I want to build something with you, with both of you.” She’s staring at me like we’re standing on the edge of something unknown, and she’s trying to decide if she trusts me enough to take this leap, if she trusts me enough to catch her.“ I just need you to give me a chance.” My voice breaks on the last word. “Just choose me,” I whisper. She doesn’t answer right away, she simply stands there, tears shining in her eyes, my heart laid bare between us. “I’m not afraid of the responsibility,” I tell her quietly. “Or the risk, or even the fact that loving you both could completely wreck me if this goes wrong. I’m afraid of leaving this kitchen knowing I didn’t fight harder for you, fight harder for this.” When the next tear slips free from her eyes and rolls down her flushed cheek, something inside me cracks wide open. “I know you’re scared,” I whisper. “I am too.”

She swallows hard. “Zach...”

“Please,” I interrupt, not harshly, not desperately, but honestly. “Let me finish.” I need her to hear me on this. “I’m not asking you to be reckless, I’m asking you to be brave with me.” Her eyes flutter closed, tears clinging to her lashes, making them clump together. I can see the fight in her, the struggle, her instinct to protect, to hold back, to keep them both safe. “I don’t have this all figured out,” I confess. “I don’t have a safety net, no way to guarantee this all works out. I only know that walking away from you, from both of you, doesn’t feel like an option anymore, not when it already feels like this.”

“I don’t know how to do this without risking everything,” she whispers.

I nod understandingly. “Neither do I, but I’m willing to try.” I finally reach up to touch her, my fingertips brushing over her cheek, gentle but sure, wiping her tears. “Because some things are worth risking everything for,” I continue softly. “And you're worth the risk, you and Zoey. I don’t want to look back and wonder what would’ve happened if I’d only fought a little harder for you.”

Paige swallows, her eyes flicking away for a moment, uncertainty flashing across her features. “I want to figure this out, but I don’t want to mess this up either.”

I bring my hand to her chin gently, urging her to meet my gaze again. “Neither do I.” My thumb brushes over the skin of her jaw, and for the first time, I can see the flicker of relief in her eyes, like maybe that was what we both needed to hear. “We’ll do this together,” I whisper, assuring her.

She nods, eyes closing. “Together.”