Page 42
I give her a small, polite nod, gripping the warm cup in one hand and the donut box in the other before heading back outside. The streets started to bustle a little more now, cars moving, people rushing toward offices and the subway, but all I can think about is who was waiting for me back at the apartment, my girls. The weight of the woman’s words lingering in my mind—I’m not Zoey’s dad, but the way she looks at me, the way she trusts me, it’s more than I deserve, and Paige has let me in more than I ever expected she would. I want to be the man they both can count on, not only for a morning coffee run, not only for late-night laughs and help around the house, but for everything. By the time I reach the front door, my pulse has kicked up and I hesitate a second before stepping inside. The second I open the door, I can already hear them, Zoey’s excited chatter and Paige’s soft laughter, and when I step in the living room, they are both sitting there in their pajamas, looking at me, sleep still clinging to their similar features, but their smiles are still wide and bright.
“Zach!” Zoey squeals, running toward me, her tiny feet pattering against the floor, her eyes zeroing in on the box in my hand. “Did you get me something?” Zoey bounces on her toes, her eyes lighting up. “Did you get us donuts?” she asks, her voice full of wonder, like she can’t believe this is really happening.
I kneel down to her level, holding the box open for her with a grin. “I got you the best donut, a pink one with rainbow sprinkles, you’re going to love it,” I announce to her, revealing the donuts.
She squeals with excitement and immediately reaches for it, her hands eager to grab the sweet treat. She grabs it carefully, well, as carefully as Zoey can manage and takes a huge bite, frosting smearing across her cheek. “Careful, Zo.” I laugh, reaching out to wipe the frosting with my thumb.
“I’m careful,” she insists, mouth full, crumbs and sprinkles falling everywhere.
“Clearly.”
I catch a glimpse of Paige watching us, her meeting mine, lingering a second too long before drifting to the coffee in my hand. A slow, warm smile curves her lips as I hold the cup out to her, our fingers brushing against each other as she takes it from my hands. I stand there for a moment, watching the scene unfold in front of me, Paige and Zoey, a family, not mine in any traditional sense of the word, but mine nonetheless. I met Paige’s eyes again, her smile still lingering on her lips, she doesn’t say anything, but there’s an understanding there, silent, but real. The weight in my chest, the restlessness, all of it fades away in the moment, whatever this is, whatever we're stepping into, I want it, I want her, I want them, and for the first time, I’m not afraid of admitting it. Zoey’s already bouncing again two seconds later, sugar kicking in fast. I ruffle her hair as she spins across the living room.
“Park?” I ask, glancing back at Paige.
She raises a brow, amused. “After that donut?”
“Figured we’d let her burn it off before she tears down the entire apartment.”
“I’m not tearing down anything!” Zoey shouts, dancing around the living room.
“That’s debatable,” I mumble, her energy unstoppable as always. “Are you ready to go?” I ask, my gaze flicking to Paige.
Before anyone can help her, Zoey is already tugging on her shoes, determined to do everything herself. Her small hands fumble with the velcro, her brows furrowed in concentration. I crouch down beside her, offering a hand to help, but she shakes her head, her little voice firm. “I can do it, Zach!” she proclaims, her green eyes wide and serious, making me laugh despite myself.
“Alright, kiddo, but don’t blame me if those shoes come undone,” I say, watching her as she carefully straps them before standing, satisfied with her work, beaming at me.
Zoey declares herself done with morning preparations and is already halfway to the door before either of us can catch up. I follow her out of the living room, but my gaze drifts back to Paige one more time as she finishes what she’s doing, the light pouring in around her like she belongs right there in the center of it, then she’s falling into step with us, all three of us, moving forward together. I tell myself it’s only a walk to the park, something simple, something normal, but nothing about this morning feels entirely simple anymore. Zoey doesn’t hesitate for even a moment, immediately running ahead of us with that endless energy of hers, her laughter echoing down the sidewalk as she makes a beeline for the park. Paige ends up walking beside me without either of us saying a word, the space between us isn’t awkward, but it carries everything unspoken since last night, everything still lingering between us, and instead of pulling back and running from it, I find myself staying right here in it.
The sun is rising higher now, washing the world in soft gold as we take the short walk to the park a few blocks from the apartment. Zoey fills the space between us with her usual brightness, her excitement spilling out before we even get there.
“Can we go on the swings first, Zach?” she asks, slipping her hand into mine like it’s instinct, and it feels so natural that I don’t even think before squeezing her little hand back softly.
“Of course, kiddo,” I agree, walking toward the swings. “I’ll push you,” I add, holding onto her hands as she jumps into one of the swings and holds on.
I push her gently, letting her little giggles fill the air. “Higher, Zach! Higher!”
Paige stands off to the side, watching the two of us, her expression soft but unreadable. For a moment, I wonder if she is wondering the same thing I am: where do we go from here? She watches as I give Zoey another gentle push, sending her into the air with a squeal of excitement. I can’t remember the last time I’ve done something like this, and moments like this are the kind of moments you don’t want to let slip away. I keep my gaze on Zoey as she soars higher, her face lighting up with joy, there is something so pure about her laughter, so full of life, that it makes everything else fade into the background.
A voice interrupts my thoughts. “What a beautiful family you have,” a woman says as she walks past us with a warm, kind smile.
I glance over to find her watching us, her eyes full of that gentle kind of warmth you usually only see in the eyes of someone who has lived long enough to understand the value of moments like this. I freeze for a split second, not knowing how to react. What a beautiful family you have. The words echo in my mind as though I’d heard them in a dream, but this isn’t a dream, this is real, this is me, standing here watching the woman and child I’ve somehow grown to care for so deeply, and suddenly, it feels like maybe I’m seeing it through someone else’s eyes, and I realize this isn’t something I’m on the outside observing anymore, it’s something I’m already become a part of. Paige pauses beside me, not pulling away, not tensing, simply caught in the moment like she wasn’t expecting to hear those words out loud. Her eyes track the woman for a second, and when she smiles, it’s small and composed, but it doesn’t fully mask what’s underneath.
“Thank you,” she replies after a beat, her voice steady but softened at the edges, like the words take a second to fully land before she allows them to take root. Paige doesn’t correct it, she doesn’t challenge it. The woman glances at Zoey and I, her eyes softening as she watches the little girl fly through the air.
“Cherish them,” the woman says, her voice low but full of meaning, like she knows something we don’t. Then, just as quickly, she turns and walks away, leaving behind a lingering sense of both blessing and weight.
I can’t shake the words, cherish them. It isn’t the first time I’ve heard it, but for some reason, it feels different now, it feels like a reminder, one I’m not sure I’m ready for but one I simply can’t ignore, not anymore. I take a deep breath and look between Zoey and Paige, whose gaze meets mine for a fleeting moment. There is something there, something real. We’re no longer simply two people coexisting in the same space anymore. Something happened last night, and now, standing here, I can feel it in every nerve in my body, in every beat of my heart. I feel the weight of everything that has happened settle into my chest. The kiss hadn’t only meant something, it meant everything, but what does that mean for all of us? I watch Zoey laugh, her little face glowing as the wind whips through her curls. She is so carefree, so sure of herself that it makes something inside me ache. Maybe it’s the hope that I can be part of this, part of their life, that I can be more than another guy who passed through for them. When Paige looks at me, there’s no mistaking it this time, no uncertainty to hide behind, only something real and unguarded that meets me exactly where I am, and instead of questioning it, I meet it right back because for the first time, I’m not wondering if I belong here or how this all fits together, I know that we do, that I want this, that I’m choosing them. Zoey’s laughter rings out as I push her higher, and it feels like everything inside me locks into place at once. This isn’t about being ready or having it all figured out, it’s about showing up and meaning it, which I do because I’m all in.
23
You’re A Good Man, Zachary Harrison
ZACH
Even though we left the park hours ago, everything that happened is still lingering in my mind, the older woman’s words, the sound of Zoey’s laughter, the way Paige kept staring at me when she thought I wasn’t looking. The way it all feels so easy, so right, that it scares the hell out of me because for the first time in my life, I’m not trying to talk myself out of this, I’m not searching for a way to create distance or looking for a reason to pull away before things get too real. There’s no voice in my head telling me to keep this friendly, to keep it casual, to leave myself an out because somewhere along the way, that former instinct disappeared. That voice, the doubt, the hesitation, it all went away, and what replaced it feels a hell of a lot like certainty. This isn’t casual, it hasn’t been for a while, and I’m done pretending I don’t already know what I want, I don’t only want the big moments with them, I want to be there for the small moments and the hard ones, too. I want the responsibility that comes with loving them, the permanence of being a part of their lives. I want to belong in their orbit instead of circling from a distance, pretending that their gravity hasn’t already pulled me in. I’m choosing them, not eventually, not maybe, now, but more than anything, I want to be chosen by them in return.
This isn’t about what happened today, this isn’t about what happened last night, that kiss wasn’t the start of something, it simply forced me to stop ignoring what’s already been building for a while now. If I keep waiting, if I don’t tell her how I feel, if I let Paige keep believing this is something I could walk away from, I know exactly what’s going to happen, she’ll pull back. She’ll convince herself she was right to be careful, and then I’ll lose this before I ever get a real chance, and I’m not letting that happen.