Page 140

Ivy hasn’t said anything. Ivy’s just crying, watching me.

I know I’m supposed to say something. I can feel all three of them waiting for it, even Charlie’s gone still somehow, and I am nowhere. I’m seventeen in a parking lot. I’m on my couch with a bowl of soup. I’m doing the math I’ve done my whole life, the who’s-left math, and the number keeps coming out smaller.

Harper moved.

And now Ivy. Ivy, twenty minutes away. Ivy, who I’ve driven a meal to on every bad day for years. Ivy, who grabbed a stranger’s hand on a dare and started this whole thing, the last of the three of us still in reach.

Gone.

To the same little town. The two of them an hour and a half away with their husbands and their babies and their farmhouses and their slow, beautiful lives, and me here, in Dallas, holding a life I built to never disappoint me.

Ivy is watching me come apart. I can see her seeing it. And I understand, with total clarity, that if I let her see the whole thing, she will not go. Ivy would give up the farmhouse and the animals and the slow life to keep from breaking my heart, because that’s who she is. And I would rather cut off my own hand than let her.

So I do the thing.

I do the exact thing I sat in a folding chair three hours ago and hated Natalie for.

I put the front on.

I stand up and go around the table and pull Ivy up out of her chair and into a hug, and I make my voice do the thing, warm and sure and steady, not one crack in it.

“Ivy. This is wonderful. This is the most you thing I have ever heard, a farmhouse and goats and the whole slow beautiful life. You’re going to be so happy out there. And you’ll be right next to Harper. I’m going to come out so much you’ll be sick of me. I’ll have my own room.”

She searches my face, wanting so badly to believe me, and I give her nothing to doubt, because I’m good at this. I’m the best there is at this. Giving people the version that lets them off the hook.

“I thought you’d be sad,” she says, hopeful. “I’ve been sick about it for a week. I thought you’d be here all alone and it’d be my fault.”

“Sad? Ivy, I have Luke. I have Bo and Dottie. I have church, I have a whole life. I’m not alone. I’m the opposite of alone. I’m happy. I’m so happy for you.”

And she believes me.

Relief washes over her whole face, and she hugs me again, hard, and says she loves me, and I say it back, and I mean that part with everything I have.

Everything else was a front.

Same as Natalie’s.

I judged her for it this morning, and I’m doing it at one this afternoon, over garlic and a baby, and the only difference between us is that nobody is going to catch me, because I am so much better at it than she is.

I hold it through dessert. I hold it through the goodbye, through one more hug, through Gray walking me out and saying thank you for being happy about it, it means everything, and me telling him of course, drive safe with that baby.

I hold it until I’m three blocks away and there’s a red light and no one in the car but me.

Then it comes.

I don’t cry pretty. I’ve watched a thousand people cry and there’s a kind that’s release and a kind that’s just a body giving out, and this is the second kind. It comes up out of me at a light on Greenville and I put both hands over my mouth like I can keep it in, and I can’t.

Because here is the whole day, all at once, and it fits together too well.

This morning, a room full of people I let myself trust, and the proof, right in the middle of it, that the warm ones are the biggest liars of all, that you cannot tell the front from the true thing.

I walked back into a church and handed these people my whole self, and any one of them could be crying in a parking garage behind a happy caption.

Community isn’t safe. It was never safe. I knew that for ten years and I let a good sermon and a good man talk me out of it.

And tonight, the other half.

The two people who were supposed to be the exceptions, the ones who were never a front, both of them gone to the same little town where their lives get to be full and slow and mine gets to be quiet. Everyone leaves. Everyone I let close eventually points their whole life at somewhere that isn’t me, and goes.