Page 139
But I’m not in that chair.
I’m in the other one. The one where I’ve spent four months watching this exact woman post her mother a dozen ways a month. I have sat on my couch and looked at those pictures and felt the specific ache of a woman who talks to her own mother four times a year, and I have thought, some people just get that. Some people get the warm, loud, easy version. Good for her.
And it was a front.
That’s the word my brain hands me, fast, before I can stop it.
Front.
The whole warm thing, the my-best-friend thing, the captions and the cheek-to-cheek, all of it laid over a girl who cries in parking garages. On stage, one thing. Off stage, another. Grace on the feed. Guilt in the car.
I know this behavior. I learned it at seventeen, from a woman I trusted with my whole new faith. I didn’t have the tools then to hold the gap, so I just left. Both of them. The people and God. Because if the closest ones are performing, then none of it is real, and none of it is safe.
I’m twenty-seven now. I have the tools. I hand them to people for a living.
And I’m sitting in a folding chair watching my own hands shake around a coffee cup, because the tools have all gone out the window and the only thing left in the room with me is a seventeen-year-old’s rule, back from the dead, loud as the day I wrote it.
They will always let you down.
After, I do the thing I know how to do. I find Natalie by the coffee and put my hand on her arm and say the right words in the right order, that I’m glad she said it, that it was brave, that she’s not alone in it. I watch myself do it from somewhere far off, and it’s good work, it’s kind, and she hugs me and says I always know what to say, which is the worst thing anybody’s said to me all day.
That’s not true. I mean it for her. I’d mean every word of it from the chair.
What I can’t do is stop the other thing running underneath, cold and fast and certain, the thing that isn’t about Natalie at all. If she’s this, then who else. If the girl who calls me her real friend has a whole hidden life behind a happy caption, then what is any of this, this room, these people, the warm Sunday feeling I let myself start to trust. What did I walk back into. What did I let all the way in.
I get to my car and sit there a second longer than I need to, both hands on the wheel, and I tell myself I’m being ridiculous. One person. One hard relationship she was honest about. That is not a conspiracy. That is a woman I love telling the truth in the one place she felt safe enough to.
The tools know that.
But the tools aren’t driving anymore. The seventeen-year-old is, and she’s already counting exits, and I put the car in reverse and drive to the surest thing I have left, which is Ivy.
Ivy and Gray’s condo smells like garlic, and there’s a baby gate that wasn’t there last month, and Charlie’s in a bouncer batting at a toy, and it’s all so normal that I feel my shoulders start to come down for the first time since class. This I know. Ivy hands me a glass of sweet tea I won’t finish and Gray’s at the stove and Charlie shrieks with joy at the sight of me, which is objectively the best thing that’s happened all day.
For a little while it’s just easy. Just us. I let it be.
Over lunch I reach for the joke I’ve been teasing Gray with for weeks.
“So when are you actually coming back to worship? Charlie’s four months old. This is the longest paternity leave in church history. Pastor Jack’s going to start charging you rent on the green room.”
Gray sets down his fork. He looks at Ivy. And Ivy looks at him, and something moves between them, a whole silent conversation, and I feel the temperature of the room change before either of them says a word, because I read rooms, and this one just turned.
“I’m not coming back,” Gray says. “To worship. We’ve been meaning to tell you. We just kept not doing it.”
“Oh.” I recalibrate. “Gray, that’s fine, that’s more than fine. The album, the film, of course you’re stepping back, you don’t need the worship-team paycheck anymore. You’ve earned it. Are you doing your own ministry stuff now?”
“Free lessons, mostly. Kids who can’t afford them. That part’s really good.”
“Then why do you both look like somebody died?”
Neither of them laughs.
Ivy’s eyes are already full. She reaches across the table and takes Gray’s hand, and he wraps his other one around it, and I watch two people brace each other for something, and the cold thing from this morning stirs in my chest and wakes all the way up.
“We’re moving, Liv,” Gray says.
The room goes very still, except for Charlie, oblivious, delighted, batting her toy.
“We found a place. In Ashen Mills. A farmhouse, a little land, enough room for Charlie to run, for us to have some animals, do the slow thing we always said we’d do when we had kids.” He lays it down soft, like soft will hurt less. “We can be close to Ivy’s parents. Harper’s there. The church out there’s been asking me to help mentor their worship team. It just all lined up. It felt like God opening a door.”
