AllFreeNovel
Share Us
As if reading my mind, Eli says, “Oh, baby boy. She knows you liked it. She saw how hard you were. And while there was no audio, I’m sure she could see the word ‘please’ on your lips as you begged me to keep going.”
“Oh, my fucking god,” I mutter as I take a seat on the edge of the bed to bury my face in my hands. I want to die. I want to melt away into the mattress and disappear forever.
“It’s okay, Jordan. You didn’t have a choice,” Maddie whispers from nearby.
“Don’t pretend like you didn’t enjoy every second,” Eli says. Then he adds, “Maddie why don’t you tell him what I did to you, so he feels better? Tell him how I made you beg for my tongue and my cock.”
“What?” Dropping my hands I get to my feet, looking between them, then our messy, unmade bed. Maddie always makes the bed perfectly. Not to mention the strong scent of rubber and cum in the air. “Maddie? Did he, did he restrain you too?” I search the headboard, the mattress for handcuffs or some sort of rope, but there isn’t any.
Eli cackles as if he finds the entire conversation hilarious. “No, I didn’t restrain her. All I had to do was ask, and she did whatever I wanted her to do.Maddie, get on your knees so I can fuck your mouth. Maddie, come sit your ass down on my cock and ride it. Maddie, spread your legs wider and let me eat you out again.She really loved that part. It was probably a close tie between tongue fucking and taking her from behind. She moaned my name like it was the best sex of her life. But I’m sure she comes hard like that on your dick too, right?”
“Maddie…” My throat clenches up as I stare at her, silently begging her to tell me he’s lying. That every word he’s saying isjust his way of trying to torment me, and that none of it actually happened.
Wetting her lips, keeping her eyes lowered to the floor, she says, “I made a deal with him.” A deal, she says, not a fucking denial.
“What kind of deal?”
“Three nights with him and he would let you go without hurting you.”
“Three nights? Three nightswithhim?” I exclaim, the volume of my voice rising with each word. “You mean…not three times using your body but three whole nights fucking you?”
“Last night was just the second,” she says without lifting her eyes to mine.
“Just the second…Jesus, Maddie! What were you thinking?”
She huffs and props her hands on her hips. “I was thinking that I didn’t know where you were or what he was going to do to you! The deal was to keep him from hurting you or killing you. It wasallfor you!”
“All the orgasms you had were for me. Right,” I scoff with a roll of my eyes. “And you actually thought that son of a bitch would have kept his word?” I ask her.
“He’s got you there,” Eli says.
Pointing a finger toward his face, I warn him, “You shut up and stay the fuck out of this.”
“Jordan, I’m sorry, okay? I thought…I thought that was the only thing I could do until I got up the nerve to shoot him and demand that he tell me where you were!”
“Why didn’t you shoot him the night before last?” I ask her curiously.
“That is a damn good question,” Eli agrees with a nod. “You had the gun, the one you stole from your father when you ran away, so why didn’t you shoot me the first night, Maddie?”
She chews on her thumbnail and says, “I…I guess I thought I might accidentally kill him and never find out where you were.”
“Bullshit!” I yell. “You liked it!” When she won’t look at me, I turn to Eli. “She liked it, didn’t she?”
“Hell yes, she did. I lost count of how many times she came each night.”
Wow. How am I getting more truth from Eli than Maddie about this? All she gives me is half-truths and straight-up lies.
“Did she really come while you were fucking her?” I ask him.
“So many times. Why? She doesn’t come on your cock?”
“Not usually.”
“Will you two stop talking about me like I’m not here!” Maddie exclaims.
“We’re just comparing notes,” Eli tells her. “And it looks like I should give Jordan some pointers. Maybe a demonstration would work better.”
“Shut up!” I shout at him. To her, I ask, “What the hell Maddie? How could you just let him fuck you over and over again?”
