AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Two Wrongs

Page 151

by Sam Mariano

Dread fills my gut as I navigate out of the parking lot and turn left like I always do.

I could keep going straight on my way to Tor’s apartment building.

Instead, I turn right at the corner of Main and Chestnut. I drive past the funeral home, the memory of Tim’s funeral surfacing.

I keep driving until I reach the cemetery.

I slow to a stop just inside the entrance, unsure if I really want to do this.

But I need to.

Swallowing past the lump in my throat, I make my way to where I know Tim’s body is. I know it’s there because members of the Walters family are too good to be buried in the dirt like the rest of us—they have a mausoleum.

The structure looks especially spooky in the dark.

I shift into Park but leave the engine running and open my car door. My headlights and the moon are the only sources of light.

I can’t believe I’m in a cemetery at night. This is creepy. I should have waited.

But I’m here now.

I’m not sure what I intend to do, but I walk up the steps and pull on the door.

It doesn’t open.

I wasn’t sure if it would.

The Walters family owns the mausoleum, so I guess it makes sense that it’s locked so random people can’t get inside.

And I’m the last person who deserves to be inside.

Sighing, I move back away from the door. I sit down on the top step.

“Hi,” I say, my voice coming out a little wobbly. I sit there for a long moment, just looking at the door, trying not to imagine Tim inside even though I’m talking to him.

“I don’t know if you can hear me,” I finally say. “I don’t know how death works. In case you can, I just…” I look down, shaking my head. “I’m so confused. I don’t know what to believe anymore. If there’s one thing your family is very good at, it’s making me feel crazy. Honestly, if trophies were given out… Walters family gets it in a landslide. Guess you can add that one to your trophy case.” I frown. “Though, it may not be on the wall anymore. Tor wrecked something in your bedroom last night, I’m not sure what it was.” My gaze shifts back to the door. “Anyway, I could never understand… We were friends once. Not good friends, but friendly, at least. We liked each other, didn’t we? In some capacity. And after everything, you saw how much it hurt me, and you just…” I shake my head, tears welling up in my eyes. “I could never understand why you couldn’t just say you were sorry. Why you couldn’t mean it. Because I knew if I ever hurt someone like that, even if it had been unintentional, which yours was absolutely not, I would apologize. They wouldn’t have to drag it out of me because I would mean it from the bottom of my heart. I would want to give that to them. I would feel terrible if I ever hurt someone the way you hurt me, and you couldn’t even give me the respect of an apology.” I swallow, dashing away moisture that leaks from my right eye. “I’m murky on the details right now, but if Nina is telling the truth… maybe I understand. You didn’t feel the apology was your responsibility because you knew…” I stare at the door. “But I didn’t know. Didn’t you understand that? I thought you were so callous because you were protecting yourself, but maybe you were protecting him. Either way, you did it callously. Callousness doesn’t deserve a death sentence, though, so if I was wrong, I want you to know I’m truly sorry, and I’ll carry the weight of what I did to you for the rest of my life. I know it doesn’t change anything. It’s too late. It doesn’t matter. But it would have mattered to me, so…”

I feel the tears welling again, and I’ve said all I really needed to say, so I stand, clear my throat, and turn my back to the mausoleum.

I don’t try to stop the tears this time. I let them track down my cheeks as I head back to the car.

Once I’m inside, I glance at the mausoleum one last time, knowing I won’t be back. “Goodbye, Tim.”

___

I push the key into the lock and turn it, and a moment later, I’m where Tor told me to be: inside my apartment.

My body feels heavy with exhaustion, both the emotional and physical varieties.

When I turn the corner, I expect to see Tor sitting in my living room on my couch, and I’m too tired to deny the tug of disappointment when he isn’t there.

I don’t want to talk to him, but he’s right, we do need to talk.

I don’t want him here, but it feels awful that he isn’t.

I don’t know what’s wrong with me, but I don’t waste energy trying to figure it out. I shower alone, then go straight to bed.

There’s nothing I want more than the escape of a dreamless sleep, but the moment I curl up alone in my spot on the bed, all I can focus on is the emptiness of Tor’s. The unfairness of missing the person who may have ruined my life is a lot to bear, and I don’t want to go down the paths my mind leads to when I think about that.