AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Two Wrongs

Page 138

by Sam Mariano

I’m no stranger to the viciousness of people’s single-minded defense of Tim Walters, but typically the words aren’t flung directly at me, face-to-face. I’ve been called a liar more times than I could possibly count, but Nina was there that night, and for her to attack me with such ferocity, to say such awful things we both know aren’t true…

It doesn’t make sense.

Long after Nina is out of sight, I’m still standing there trying to process, heart thudding, staring sightlessly at the sliding glass door as I pick at the thread she loosened and my entire world begins to unravel.

I tell myself to stop. I don’t have to listen to her. I know the truth. She said all that because she’s vicious, but there’s no way…

But why would she say all that when she’s only talking to me? She sounded so sure of herself, so angry. Why would she be so angry with me if she knew she was making it all up?

I notice my chest moving, the extra effort it takes to draw a breath.

What she’s saying is impossible.

I know what happened that night. I was there. I was the only one in that room with him, trapped beneath his body, his hand clamped over my mouth.

I didn’t make anything up.

I’m not crazy.

But I don’t think she is, either.

Mean, but not crazy.

She believes what she just said to me. But how could it be true, when I’m telling the truth, too?

I can’t breathe properly.

Woodenly, I turn around and walk through the kitchen. I stop and look at the entryway. I avoided it earlier. Came in the back door so I didn’t have to see it.

I walk across the stretch of floor where Tim’s body fell, then I go up the stairs.

But I don’t go to Tor’s room.

I go to Tim’s.

I’m practically wheezing by the time I get there, the effort it takes to breathe becoming a little too much. Maybe I should just stop trying because if what she said is true…

It isn’t.

It can’t be.

You know the truth.

The forceful insistence of my fracturing mind doesn’t make me feel any better, though.

I stare at Tim’s bed. It isn’t made. The sheets are still rumpled like he just climbed out of it this morning. Maybe no one could bring themselves to come into this room since he died, or maybe they left it the way he did for sentimental reasons.

Because they miss him.

He was taken from them.

Oh my god. What have I done?

I shake my head, tears welling up in my eyes, rejecting the unacceptable possibility that surfaces in my mind.

I want to lie down in the bed like I did last summer just to see what happens. Smells can trigger memories, and the pillow probably still smells like him. If it triggers the memories, I can… I can relive it and reassure myself that I’m remembering everything correctly.

It’s too horrifying to think I could have possibly been wrong. I can’t be wrong about this. I can’t be.