Page 104
“Glad I could help,” he says lightly.
“To be fair, you created the problem in the first place,” I point out.
“Hey, Nina did that. Because she’s an asshole.”
I grin. “See, I can’t even see you, and I’m like, ‘aw, he’s so smart and handsome.’”
He chuckles, then after a few seconds, he asks, “Are you feeling better?”
“No,” I mutter, but I’m not that serious. Joking around a little did help lessen the crazy, but Nina has been such a sore spot for me for so long that it’s hard to stomach any interaction between them that I can’t directly witness myself. Especially when she frames it that way, and I’ve seen her go after guys before. She always gets her way eventually. “What did she say to you?”
“I don’t know, the usual?”
“What does that mean? That’s not helpful.” I don’t give him a chance to respond. “You should have shown me how to set up a spy phone so I could have listened in on your bullshit like you listen in on mine, then I’d know the truth.”
“I’m telling you the truth,” he assures me.
“You’re not telling me anything.”
“Let’s cut through the bullshit. What is it that you need to know?” he asks, seriously.
I hesitate, trying to put it into words. “She was like… Tim’s groupie. She was his default hookup when he wasn’t dating anyone.”
“Yeah, I know.”
“And, like, the annoyingly devoted kind of hookup. Nothing he ever did shook her off. When he would sleep with someone else, she would just wait in the wings until he was hers again.”
Tor sighs. “I know all of this, Cassie.”
“So, can you see why it makes me a little uneasy that she’s posting something like that centering you now?”
“She’s just trying to get attention. Tim’s death is a hot topic right now, and guess who conveniently looks just like him.”
“Exactly. You look exactly like the guy she has been into for the past three years.”
“Yes, but I’m not him. You do not have to worry about me like this. It doesn’t even matter if she’s attracted to me because I’m not interested in her. I get that you don’t like or trust Nina, but you know me. Do you think I’m a helpless person who just gets blown wherever some girl wants me to go?”
“Well, no, of course not, but—”
He cuts me off. “I’m not like Tim. I have exactly what I want, so why do I care what else is readily available?”
“I know, but—”
“I’m not even attracted to Nina. She’s too easy for me. I have no interest in attaining something that literally anybody can have. I need a little challenge to get me interested.”
“She’ll figure that out and pivot,” I state. “You’re like a white whale to her. It wasn’t just Tim’s physical appearance she liked. It was his family’s status—your family’s status.”
“And I have the same physical appearance and status,” he says. “Yes, I understand. I know that Nina had a thing with my brother, and now that he’s gone, I’m sure she would be down for a twin swap, but her motivations are not the only ones that matter here. I have free will, and I am not interested in her. I am not a prize, Cassie. I can’t be won. I’m only interested in you, and there’s nothing she could say or do to change that.”
His words are reassuring, and I guess if I come out of the hyperfocus on what I know Nina is like, he has a point. I know what Tor is like, and I don’t have any reason to think he would be into Nina.
It’s just that every guy is into Nina.
And she is a brunette, which is the only thing he would tell me constitutes his type physically. And I know that Nina is sexier than I am. She’s widely regarded as the sexiest girl in our class. It’s not just her looks; it’s the way she interacts with people. She has a very touchy way about her, so I wasn’t surprised she would try to hug Tor, but I don’t believe that he doesn’t remember hugging her. I am completely straight, and Nina playfully caressed me one time, and I got tummy flutters. She’s not easy to resist. I don’t know a single guy in our graduating class who ever resisted her when she set her sights on them—guys with girlfriends included, she doesn’t care—so for him to tell me he has no attraction to her whatsoever… I think he’s bending the truth to make me feel better.
And if he’s bending that truth…
What other truths might he be bending?