AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Bench

Page 35

by Bash Greyson

I couldn't stay. I knew if I sat around their kitchen sipping coffee, Connor would eventually grill me on how my night ended with Derek. Connor was too perceptive. If he took one good look at me, he would have picked up on the wild, shell-shocked daze written all over my face.

So I'd thrown my gear in the back of my pickup and driven the five hundred miles north, staring down the gray asphalt of I-5 with my hands gripping the wheel so tight my knuckles were pale.

I still hadn't fully worked out how to process the emotional wrecking ball or the relentless craving I'd been carrying around for a full week. Guys didn't just casually contemplate rearranging twenty-six years of living in a single week over one kiss, but here I was, doing just that. I wasn't panicking about it anymore, not the way I probably should have been. Derek had quietly become an unshakeable fact, sitting in my chest right alongside everything else: the job, the house, Emily. He stood right in the center of it all, casting a shadow over a future I thought was already set in stone.

When I'd tried to dodge that flirtatious girl by the pool in Mexico, repeating my usual "I have a girlfriend" excuse, it had felt like delivering a line from a movie I didn't even want to watch. Back home, Emily was waiting. Sweet, dependable Emily, who had her career at the salon, who wanted us to get a larger place together, pick out furniture together, and slip right into the comfortable future my mother had spent months trying to orchestrate for us.

And yet, every single time I'd used that excuse to brush someone off, my brain didn't think about Emily. It drifted straight back to a chance encounter on a beach. To the warmth of a small, smooth hand in mine. To shared laughter lingering on an oceanfront terrace.

And then came the dive bar. Then came the patio behind the building.

God, that kiss.

It had knocked the wind right out of my sails. The second Derek’s lips brushed against mine, my rational mind completely short-circuited. I didn't push him away. I didn't hesitate. I didn't panic about the fact that I was kissing a man, or that his body was so entirely different from what I knew. Instead, some raw, instinctual side of me simply took over. My hands slammed into his waist, dragging his lithe frame flush against my chest with a sudden hunger that rattled me to my bones.

Derek was lighter and smaller than me, but the firm, tight lines of his body didn't feel foreign—they felt intoxicating. Feeling his soft skin under my calloused hands, feeling his heat pressed flush against me—it blew right past rational thought. No second-guessing, no guilt. Just an urgent, heavy pull that made me want to hold him tight and never let go.

And then he'd just walked off into the night.

He'd left me standing under those amber patio lights, gasping for air, completely turned inside out. He hadn't even given me his phone number.

That was the thought that had been gnawing at my gut all week. Was it just a casual game to him? Straight-boy experimentation? Was he sitting at some upscale rooftop bar in San Diego right now, sipping expensive tequila and telling his friends about some nobody construction worker he'd messed with on the beach?

The sour thought had crept into my head while I was operating a skid-steer on Tuesday, but the moment it formed, my instinct rejected it completely.

No, I'd thought, feeling a protective wave wash over me. Not my sweet Derek.

He might be a brat who called me mountain man, but Derek was genuine. You couldn't fake the affection in his eyes whenever he talked about his family, or the way his face lit up when he good-naturedly complained about his two loud sisters and his momma. You couldn't fake that vibrant, easy warmth that practically pulled people into his orbit, or the playful spark that had been crackling between us from the second we met. But most of all, you couldn't fake the needy whimper he'd let slip into my mouth when I kissed him.

The phrase lingered in my mind like a stubborn truth: My sweet Derek.

To keep from losing my mind, I'd thrown myself into my work all week. We'd just broken ground on the commercial build on Monday, and between the heavy labor and today's ruptured pipe at the site, I hadn't given myself a moment to rest. Instead of staying in the air-conditioned site trailer to review blueprints, I'd grabbed my hard hat and tool belt and gotten dirty alongside my crew. I set forms, tied rebar, and worked until my shoulders burned, trying to exhaust the restless energy humming under my skin.

I'd tried my best not to act distant around Emily, either. But sitting down to dinner with her and my parents on Saturday night was the first time I'd seen her since San Diego, and stepping back into our old rhythm felt fake. I tried to play the part of the good boyfriend. Everything felt routine and predictable. My dad talked shop, my mom talked about paint colors, and Emily reached across the table to hold my hand.

When the conversation turned to my house, Emily had dropped another one of her casual comments about its layout. "It's a great starter house for a bachelor," she'd said, smiling at my mom, "but two bedrooms and one bath isn't really functional for a family long-term. We definitely need to find a place we can actually grow into."

My dad and I had spent two long years completely gutting this small craftsman, rebuilding the frame, custom-milling the oak trim, and hand-setting the stone counters. I loved this house. It gave me a deep, quiet satisfaction—the kind I rarely got on job sites anymore. Managing commercial developments or building second extensions on a millionaire’s winter cabin paid the bills, but it didn't leave room for fine details or building something meant to be lived in and loved. The idea of trading this place in for some cookie-cutter suburb made my throat pull tight, but I just forced a smile and stayed quiet.

Right as our meals arrived, my phone buzzed in my pocket with the alert about the ruptured water main. My site foreman said he could slap a patch on it to hold overnight, but it meant I had to be out there early in the morning to do the real repair. When I dropped Emily off at her place afterward, she'd given me a sly, lingering look and invited me inside. I used the pipe emergency as my excuse to head home early, kissing her cheek before slipping back to my truck.

Kissing Emily had felt like going through the motions—safe and familiar but completely lacking heat. Standing in front of her, all I could focus on was the ghost of Derek's hands wrapped around the back of my neck. I felt like a total hypocrite. Here I was, feeling guilty like I was stepping out on a man who hadn't even called me, when the actual betrayal was standing right in front of me—the girl I'd been dating for six months, whose heart I was breaking in secret.

During that same dinner, I'd casually mentioned to my family and Emily that I'd probably need to fly down to San Diego in a few weeks to help Connor pick out suits for the wedding. I hadn't mentioned Derek at all; I just framed it like Connor was falling behind on preparations and needed his best man to step in.

"You're going to fly?" my dad had grunted, looking at me like I'd lost my mind. "I thought you hated airplanes? You complained the entire week after you flew to New York three years ago for Jack's wedding."

"It's an hour flight, Dad," I'd muttered, keeping my eyes fixed on my plate. "It's easier than driving eight hours down I-5."

It was a big deal, though. I hated airports, hated security lines, and hated being crammed into a tiny row. But if spending an hour in the air meant getting to stand in the same room with Derek again, I would have sat on the wing of the plane without hesitating.

Now, sitting in the quiet twilight of my living room on Sunday night, the house felt still.

I took another long sip of my beer, setting the bottle down on the coffee table next to a stack of dirt-stained job permits. That's when my eyes caught the screen of my phone. I remembered seeing a few notifications flash across the lock screen earlier in the afternoon while I was in the trench, but I'd been too busy to stop and check them.

I reached out, picking up the phone and tapping the display. My heart did a violent thud against my ribs.

There were three unread text messages sitting in my inbox, all sent from a 619 San Diego area code—a number I didn't have saved. My thumb hovered over the screen, slightly unsteady, before tapping the thread.