Page 19
"I want you to stop coming to my openings with a notebook," Dana said.
The moderator got it back inside ninety seconds and the panel finished and forty people filed out. The video had been posted the following Tuesday and had, according to the counter, been watched nineteen thousand times, which in this town meant everyone.
Isla wrote the date on her pad and drew a box around it.
February 8.
Three days before Dana Kelsey walked down to a basement office and signed a binder for a third fob.
She sat back.
Careful, she thought. That's a shape. You are making a shape. And underneath it, in block capitals, she wrote: COINCIDENCE UNTIL PROVEN OTHERWISE — WHAT ELSE HAPPENED THAT WEEK?
Then she pulled Victor Hale.
Victor Alan Hale, fifty-one. Address on Wisconsin Avenue in Superior, a rented house four blocks off the bay. Minnesota DL surrendered for a Wisconsin one in 2016. Six feet one, two hundred and thirty pounds. Two vehicles registered: a 2009 Chevy Express cargo van and a Subaru with a lapsed tab.
BFA, Kansas City Art Institute, 1997. And a career that read, page by page, like the inverse of Dana Kelsey's — early, fast, and then twenty years of decline. Represented in Chicago at twenty-eight. A New American Paintings entry in 2001. Two museum group shows before he was thirty-five, and then a slow subtraction: smaller galleries, then regional galleries, then a stretch where the only hits were juried county shows and a mural commission in Rice Lake. He taught. He'd taught a lot of places and had not stayed at any of them; UW-Superior had him as adjunct faculty from 2014 to 2019 and then didn't, and Isla put a note beside that too because and then didn't was a sentence with a story in it.
He was, everyone agreed, extremely good. That was the part that stopped her. She found a 2019 review in a Milwaukee paper that used the word virtuoso twice, more or less as an accusation, and a 2022 interview in which Hale himself said that the worst thing that had ever happened to him was that painting had come easily at nineteen.
Isla read that sentence four times and then went and found images.
She sat with them for twenty minutes: nine paintings from the show in Superior, shot badly for a gallery's website. Low horizon. Piers from the left. Weather on top.
They were fast. Even through a bad JPEG on a Bureau monitor, she could see it — the long single strokes, no correction, the confidence of a hand that never went back. He worked wet into wet. He worked alla prima. He put a stroke down and he left it.
She sat very still for a moment with her hand flat on the desk.
Then she pulled his criminal history, and there it was, in Ramsey County, 2016.
The Ostergaard Gallery on St. Peter Street had represented Victor Hale for two years and dropped him in the September, and on the night of October fourth a man matching his description had come down the sidewalk with a five-gallon pail and thrown roughly four gallons of used mineral spirits and mixed pigment across the gallery's front windows, the door, and eleven feet of sidewalk. The window had held. The pigment had gotten into the mortar and had never entirely come out. He'd been arrested at his hotel at two in the morning with his hands still stained. Criminal damage to property, gross misdemeanor, pled down to a misdemeanor with restitution of eleven thousand dollars and a year of unsupervised probation, and a no-contact order that had expired in 2018.
There was a second incident nine months later that had generated an incident number and no charges: a complaint from a different gallery, in Minneapolis, about a man who had come to three consecutive openings and stood in front of one particular artist's work for a long time and had made two employees uncomfortable enough to write it down. The complainant had declined to proceed. The name of the artist wasn't in the report.
Isla read the report twice, and then she got up and stood at her window with her arms folded.
It was ten fifty-one in the morning. Out past Superior Street the lake had gone the flat pewter of a November noon, and the sea smoke was long gone, and the horizon sat exactly where it always sat, four hundred feet from a fourth-floor studio where the radio was probably still on.
She could feel the shape trying to close, and she stood there and refused to let it.
Because it fit. It fit almost perfectly — a man who had come apart publicly in front of a room, three days before a fob went missing; a man who had thrown paint at a building for taking his work away; a man who painted at speed and painted the exact composition and had a cargo van and lived twelve minutes across the bridge. If she took that to Channing right now, she'd get a warrant application by three.
And a man like that killed you in a parking lot, or he threw a pail at your window, or he wrote nine hundred words about you on the internet at four in the morning. He did not walk in through the one door without a camera with a fob he'd stolen nine months in advance, kill you with one blow, sit you up in a chair, and then spend two and a half hours making your painting better.
That was not rage. Isla had been standing over rage her entire adult life and she knew what its handwriting looked like, and this was not it. This was somebody finishing something.
Or, she thought — and made herself say it fully, because the whole discipline was in saying it fully — or it's exactly him, and I don't want it to be him, because I have spent eight months learning to be afraid of a different man, and a case that closes in eleven days with a painter from Superior would embarrass a fear I've built a whole year around.
She went back to the desk and wrote it down. Both. Side by side, as Delgado had taught her in a classroom in Quantico twenty years ago: the reading you like, and the reason you like it.
Then she picked up the phone and dialed the bullpen.
"Marshall. Drop the log for ten minutes, CART won't be up till one." She was already pulling a fresh folder out of the drawer and writing a name on the tab. "Victor Alan Hale, H-A-L-E, DOB to follow. Superior, Wisconsin. I want everything — full criminal, financials, cell if we can articulate it later, and every gallery that's shown him in the last five years. Then find me where he was on Monday night."
A pause. Marshall was writing; she could hear the pen.
"Person of interest?" he said.