AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Yule Be Hearing From My Lawyer

Page 2

by Caroline Frank

“So we file the OSC on the boiler and build the answer.”

“With what staff? With what hours? It’s December ninth. We’d have less than two weeks.”

“We’ll get it done with the hours we’ve got.” He shrugs that way he always does. It is the most effortless gesture I have ever seen a human being make, and it almost makes me want to throw my binder at his head. Almost, because the binder is way too perfect to ruin on Alex.

“Alex, this is⁠—”

“No, you’re so⁠—”

“Please.” Constance cuts us off and takes off her glasses with a sigh. Around the table, our colleagues—Priya from the housing unit, Daniel from intake, the two fellows who are too new to know better than to enjoy this—go very still. I know Alex and I have become the office’s favorite tennis match to watch, but I don’t want to give them any more entertainment. “I am tired of this right now. Can we please focus on the task at hand instead of letting this competitiveness get in the way of the wellbeing of eleven families?”

Alex and I mumble guilt-ridden apologies before she continues.

“Okay, here’s what’s going to happen,” Constance starts. I know that tone. Immediately, I ready my pen before she even gets a chance to finish her sentence.

“Marisol, you’re right about the OSC. Alex, you’re right about the pattern. You both make really good points, and I feel like you’d bring the right strategies to the table for this. Rather than pick one of you to take the lead, both of you are co-leading this.”

I drop my pen on the table with a loud clank.

“Both of you,” she restates, in case there was any ambiguity, and there was not. She looks between me and Alex for a moment before proceeding. “You file the emergency motion on the boiler situation. You build the consolidated answer. You go to Jackson Heights, and you sit down with every single family to hear them and their story out. I want the landlord’s counsel to walk into the Queens Housing Court on the twenty-second of December and see the two of you at the same table and feel it in his goddamn knees. I want them to know that they can’t keep taking advantage of the little guy anymore. Not while we’re around.”

“I get what you’re saying, but Constance⁠—”

“And since we’re all here,” she says, getting to her feet. “Our board meets on the twenty-second, as well. As you know, we’re looking to fill the role of Deputy Director. I told them I’m recommending one of you two, and I’ve told them I’d make the recommendation based on what I see this month. So.” She smiles and walks to the door, stopping only to say, “Show me what you’re made of.”

The silence is so intense we can almost hear the snowfall as it hits the windows.

Alex tips his chair back again. “Well,” he says to himself. “Happy Holidays.”

I take the N train home to Astoria, and I do not think about Alexander Francis Whitlock.

I do not think about him on the platform at Canal Street, where just outside the station the snow has turned to slush and a man is playing “Jingle Bells” on the saxophone. I don’t think about him over the Queensboro Bridge, when I see New York City lit up like a Christmas tree. I don’t think about him on the walk from the station, past my favorite bakery with the most perfect fluffy donuts in the window. I don’t think about him as I pass the local bodega cat, rapping at its home’s door to get back inside and away from the cold. And I definitely don’t think about him once I shut the door to my apartment, pressing my back to it with my eyes squeezed shut, trying to block out the fact that we’re going to have to work closely on this case together for the next couple of weeks.

Once I calm down, I kick off my boots and put them on the mat, toes out. I hang my blazer—charcoal, wool, dry-clean only—on the wooden hanger it lives on in my closet. I take the pins out of my honey brown hair, which comes down past my shoulder blades in loose waves, and I brush it the way my mother taught me when I was a child—the ends first and work your way up. After, I go into my closet and take every single thing out and put it all back in by color and sleeve length.

The whole process is absurd, I’ll admit, and it takes about two hours, but cleaning helps settle my mind, and I need that right now.

My mother worked as a teacher by day and bartender by night so I could work at a place like the NYIJC one day. She put in the time and effort so I could get the best education in the country. She showed me what hard work and dedication is. She taught me never to walk away from anything.

I didn’t walk out of grad school. I graduated first in my class at the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School by a margin so thin my Constitutional Law professor called it “a rounding error with personality.” Second in the class was none other than Alexander Whitlock, who slept through half of Civil Procedure and got the highest grade in it, anyway. Who showed up to Moot Court in a sweater with a hole in the elbow and made a Third Circuit judge laugh out loud. Who never once looked at me as something other than the obstacle between him and the top of that list.

But I sure as hell made it to the top.

After school, I took the job in New York because it was the best job for what I wanted. Because I wanted to help people, and the NYIJC is the most selective immigrants-rights litigation shop on the East Coast. They take eight new attorneys a year out of four hundred or so applicants. I cried in the bathroom when I received the offer email.

Also true: I took the job in New York because it wasn’t in Philadelphia. Because I had spent three years measuring every win against one specific person, and I wanted a city where I could walk into a room and know he wasn’t sitting in it. I needed to leave Alexander Whitlock behind and just be Marisol Santana without him.

My first day at the NYIJC, I walked into the conference room on the eleventh floor, and there he sat, feet propped up on a chair. Right then, I felt like I’d never escape this man.

He’d started just two weeks before me, and recruitment never thought to mention one of my classmates would be joining me. He looked up from whatever he was reading and said, “Santana” like we were picking up a conversation we had left off before graduation. In that moment, I felt something happen in my chest I cannot name that has never fully come undone.

That was four years ago. Since then, we’ve been at the same table, the same job. Our coworkers even have a betting pool on which one of us will win any given argument. I am aware that I’m usually the office favorite, which is nice. But I’m also tragically aware that this is not the same as winning.

I go back to not thinking about last December. To not thinking about the fire escape at the bar on Stone Street, or the four seconds I waited for him to do something, or what he said, or how close he was standing, or the way the door opened. He was being kind. I’d lost a case that fall that had left me defeated in more ways than one. A family sent back to a place that still gives me nightmares. I’m not thinking about the way he saw me standing outside in the cold when I was taking a minute, and he was just… nice. Or the way I mistook it for something else, and…

And I have not mistaken anything else since. I haven’t let myself leave any room for interpretation.

I close the closet door. Everything is now in order.