AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 69

by Angela Casella

“Fuck those people. Only a fool would give you up.”

“I just…” She swallows. “I want you to understand why my place here is so important to me. I came here looking for a different life. There are things I still can’t tell you. Reasons why I can’t say a word.”

“Okay.” I kiss the top of her head, needing her to know that she’s precious to me. To me, she is a phoenix feather.

“You’re the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen,” I admit, stroking her back now, running my fingers over her spine, as if I can smooth her hurt away. “You’re lit up from within. I thought so from the moment I met you.”

“From the moment I kissed you, you mean,” she whispers, lifting her head from my chest again, her glasses slightly foggy, and my sweater damp from her tears.

She stares at me with a yearning that fills me with wonder. My hand cups the back of her head, my fingers forming furrows in her long, dark auburn hair. “Before. I noticed you before that.”

She gasps.

“I barely noticed anything back then, but every time I saw your hair or your smile, I felt a little better. It was like the universe was granting me some kind of concession when you kissed me that night, right before I left.”

She lifts her hand, and I nearly flinch when she traces the scar scissoring my eyebrow, her fingers soft and warm, the blanket cocooned around us.

“I noticed you too,” she says, her words settling something within my soul.

And then she points over the fireplace, which has fairy lights draped over it, and I see it⁠—

The cinnamon broom I gave her all those years ago, preserved as if for a museum.

NINETEEN

MILES

“Emily,” I whisper. “You kept it.”

“I kept it. I treasure it. It’s my favorite broom for riding around on full moon nights.”

She really does look the part of the winter witch now, with the glow of the fairy lights around us and all her Christmas things on display, including that tiny tree I saved for her.

It’s impossible to look away from her.

I want her in a way that makes me feel a little insane.

I’d like to draw her, to paint her. I want to tattoo her on my skin so I can carry her around with me everywhere.

And yet…

I’m at war with myself. I promised Mr. Campbell I wouldn’t seduce Emily, and here I am with her straddling my lap—and a hard-on that must feel very obvious.

Oh, fuck, I’m doing it all wrong. I’m acting the way old Miles would.

If I’m going to break my word, I should do it for good purpose.

Emily deserves candlelit dinners and thoughtful gifts and soft music. She deserves a portrait painted in her honor.

She definitely deserves more than a hookup with the town delinquent.

But in that moment, I don’t just want to kiss Emily. I need it to survive.

I lower my mouth to hers, tentative at first. Part of me wonders if the magic of our connection will have faded, and this time I’ll feel nothing but the familiar act of chasing sensations that can no longer be mine.

But brushing my lips against her warm, pink mouth makes my entire body tingle with life and a raw, deep need—so different from the constant ache to outrun the pain inside of me.

With her, I want to stay. With her, I want things I know I don’t deserve yet.