AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 57

by Angela Casella

He holds my gaze as he lifts my hand and kisses it across the knuckles. “You are a fine thing. Don’t you forget it either.”

With that, he gathers the hats and leaves the shop, leaving me staring after him like a lost lamb.

SIXTEEN

MILES

A fit of madness must have overcome me in the bookshop.

It was that sweet, longing look in Emily’s eyes when she talked about supporting those kids. It felt incredibly important for someone to support her, and I’ll be damned if I didn’t want to be the man to do it.

I’ve done my best to stay away from her. Hell, I even invented an active dating life despite having zero interest in anyone but her. But that doesn’t mean I can’t support her.

I’ve wanted to show everyone, myself included, that I can be a better man—one who doesn’t run—and this seems like a good place to start.

I’m feeling pretty good about my decision to commandeer the hats until I get back to the tree stand and find six pissed-off people waiting to buy trees.

While I have a rotating list of people who’ve been helping out at the stand in addition to Whit, who can only work after school, every last one of them insisted they were sick today.

The next half hour blurs by before I have a second to relax, let alone look at those hats. Finally, I settle down onto my freezing-cold stool and look at the first of the cardboard hats, groaning when I read what it says on the back.

I’m Mark, and what I really want is an X-Box⁠—

You and me both, Mark.

—but I know no one’s going to get me that. So I’d settle for a Nintendo Switch.

Generous of you.

I check out the next one:

I want an American Girl doll more than anything, but it would be better if there were two so they can play together.

Sweat starts to gather on my brow. I don’t know much about American Girl dolls, but my sister Isabella had asked for one for Christmas years ago. The things cost so much you’d think they were stuffed with gold. Mom and Nonna had taken on some sewing work to afford the doll, and the rest of us had chipped in too. Isabella had been born last, and most of her things were hand-me-downs. We’d wanted her to have that doll.

The ho hat isn’t helping with the sweat situation, but Emily gave it to me, so it’s basically fused to my head now.

The next request is for art supplies, which makes me grin. Happy to help another starving artist in the age of AI.

There’s also one from a kid who wants to go zip-lining with his mom.

The other requests feel pretty doable, until I get to the last⁠—

I want to find the Gallagher Treasure.

I read it twice more, but it still says the same thing—and in handwriting I recognize.

Whit wrote this.

Fuck me, and I thought the expensive gifts were going to be the problem.

“What’s wrong with you?” a familiar voice says, and I glance up to see the little man himself, dressed in a coat with ripped seams. His hat is much newer and has Sir Gala-Head on it. Likely because Whit’s been going to every single one of the Advent Calendar unveilings. I’d have done the same at his age—free shit is free shit, and even if you don’t want it, you can sell it.

I’ve only gone to the A Latte a Day event. They were giving out shots of that drink I bought for Theo.

I’d give it a two out of ten. It tasted like a butterscotch left in Nonna Rose’s pocket for two years.

Before Whit can notice the little cardboard hat I’m holding, I stuff it into my pocket with the others.