AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Kissing Mr. Mistletoe

Page 126

by Angela Casella

“I’m in love with Emily, Mr. Campbell, and she’s in love with me. I didn’t mean for that to happen, but there’s no changing it.”

His mouth twitches into a pantomime of a smile. “You have a way of charming people, don’t you? So does the devil.”

“There’s something I have to tell you. Something that needs saying.” Each word costs me in blood, but I force them out, telling myself that Emily believes in me. So does Whit, and my sisters and brother. My grandmother. Luanne. Great-Uncle Ted believed in me too…

“So, go on and say it, not that you can expect me to believe a word that comes out of your mouth. A man who can’t keep his word isn’t worth the legs he stands on.”

“You had no right to ask me to stay away from her.”

His lip curls. “I had every right. I know what you are.”

I fist my hands and let the box inside of me creak the rest of the way open. “Mr. Campbell, I won’t deny that Ann would still be alive if I hadn’t gotten into the car that day. But you’re mistaken if you think I caused the crash.”

His gaze sharpens, his chin lowers. He’s waiting for me to continue, and there’s no choice.

With the box open, with the memories loose, they insist on being spoken.

“I was walking back to the farm, and Ann made Jake pull over to offer me a ride. She knew how far it was.” The words shake, but I let them keep coming. “I think she wanted me to see her with him. She was showing me she was moving on. But I wanted her to move on. Jake didn’t want me there, though, and he especially didn’t like it when she started asking about my family. He sped up, first only a little and then some more, taking the curves fast like he was out to prove something. When Ann said she’d take over, he got pissed off and said there was no way he was letting his woman question his driving.” I pause, my heart beating fast. “I tried to talk him down, but he wouldn’t hear it. He only got angrier. When he wouldn’t listen to either of us, sir, Ann tried to take the wheel. It happened at exactly the wrong moment…”

I gulp, feeling the helpless burn of fear again—of knowing I couldn’t do shit. I was a trapped passenger, and it was all going to go wrong, no matter what I did, and I was the fucking idiot who’d gotten us there by accepting the ride from hell.

For a moment, I’m back in that car, my body pinned down by that tree branch. The reverberations of the crash ringing in my ears.

I’d screamed her name until I couldn’t speak, trying to reach for her, my hand covered in her blood and mine and probably Jake’s.

My ears are buzzing, my knees are weak, and Mr. Campbell’s staring at me like a broken man.

“Let’s assume you’re telling me the truth,” he finally says, his voice cold and hard. “Why are you only saying this now?”

I know in that moment that it won’t be enough. I’ve finally opened the box and let the memories flow over me, through me, and it won’t matter to him. But I owe him a final piece of honesty.

“If I’d been able to love her like she deserved, it wouldn’t have happened. It seemed better to say I didn’t remember.”

He takes his glasses off and rubs his eyes before setting them down on the desktop. “You’re saying it wouldn’t have happened if you’d loved her the right way, but you want me to give you another shot with someone else that I love?”

“I’m a changed man. I’ve learned from my mistakes.”

“Ann didn’t get that chance.”

I can feel the heat leaking from my eyes, but I stand tall. I won’t be embarrassed, not by this. “No, sir, she didn’t, and it’s not fair. Nothing will make it fair, and if I could take back everything that happened that day I would. She was a good person. A wonderful person.”

“But you think you can love Emily better than you loved my Ann.”

“I think I’ve grown up.”

He sneers at me. “Have you? You’ve been running from your part in this for years.”

“And Emily stopped me from running. That night you threw me out of here five years ago”—I lift a hand—“as was your right, she came out after me, and she gave me a book, sir. It was a book she’d written. Did you know she’d written a book?”

He looks taken aback.

“She did, and it’s the most beautiful thing I’ve ever read. The Phoenix’s Feather. You have it here in the shop, or you did. When I finally got my shit together and read it, I came back to face my past and build a life for myself. That’s what I intend to do, sir. Because if I keep running from everything I love, I won’t be doing any justice to Ann. Or Jake. Neither of them deserved what happened. It just…happened. And I can’t take it back by wishing to, or by ruining my own life.”

His eyes are shining now too, and for a moment I think he’ll yield. But he clamps his lips into a line, his face weary. “I told Emily today that I’m ready to retire. The part I didn’t tell her is that I’d planned on giving her the bookstore and moving to Pennsylvania to live with my daughter. But I can’t do that, son, if you’re going to be hanging around, reaping the benefit. I won’t be giving you a single thing, which means I can’t give her a single thing either.”

“You’d destroy me through her?” I ask, my voice shaking, my whole being torn apart by rage and grief. “She sees you as family.”

“You think I want this?” he asks, his eyes shiny with tears. “You should have stayed the fuck away from this place. You’re a disease. You can’t expect me to believe that’s changed. That’s the essence of who you are.”