Page 20
The pasta was good, a simple tomato sauce with garlic and basil, and while he served it he told me he’d called his mother for the recipe and she’d laughed, because it was the first time he’d ever asked her for one.
“She thinks I’m turning into a different person out here,” he said. “I told her I was just trying not to set the house on fire again, and she said that cooking for a date instead of getting takeout was a sign of personal growth.”
I felt unreasonably pleased that Theo had gone to all that trouble for me.
“She’s not wrong.”
“She’s never wrong. It’s one of her most irritating qualities.”
I could tell by his indulgent smile that he loved his mother, which made me miss my own, even though she’d passed away years ago.
“Does she know you’re staying in Clover Ridge longer than you planned?”
“She knows the renovation’s taking longer than I planned,” he said. “I left out the part where I stopped minding.”
I looked at him when he said that. He was twisting pasta around his fork and not looking at me, which was the tell I’d learned to watch for. Theo aimed his jokes at you and his honest statements at whatever he was holding.
“When did you stop minding?” I asked.
“Honestly? Somewhere around the second week. Gray was telling me about the Hale family history, Jess was bringing me coffee I hadn’t ordered, and Deb next door had started leaving casseroles on the porch. It hit me that I’d been here two weeks, and more people knew my name than in any other place I ever lived. And I kind of like it.”
“That’s how it works here. We’re all nosy as hell, but we show up for our neighbors, especially when they’re new to town.”
“That’s not how it works anywhere else.”
That sounded sad, but I didn’t comment.
“Anyway, my mother doesn’t understand why I’m here at all. If it were up to her, she would have hired a realtor to take care of cleaning out the house and never come in the first place.”
“Maybe that’s why Constance left the house to you,” I suggested. “Because she knew you’d appreciate it more.”
Theo looked thoughtful. “Yeah, maybe you’re right.”
As we ate our dinner he asked about work, and I told him about a brush fire on the county line that had taken most of an afternoon last week. Then he asked about Nate, so I told him about the time Nate gave a safety presentation at the elementary school and the engine’s horn went off in the middle of it and three kids cried.
“Did Nate cry?” Theo asked.
“Nate doesn’t cry. He apologizes in a way that makes the situation worse, and then he apologizes for making it worse, and then Frank tells him to stop talking.”
“I love that dynamic,” he said, grinning.
“It’s less fun when you’re living it.”
“It’s very fun from the outside,” he said. “I work in corporate America, where everyone is politically correct and mostly keeps to themselves other than the occasional team lunch or happy hour.”
The idea of working in an office was foreign to me, but it didn’t sound like a lot of fun. I studied Theo, wondering if he liked it, or if he was just used to it because that’s all he knew.
We finished all the pasta and most of the wine, chatting easily like we’d been doing this for years. I watched him clear the plates, moving between the sink and the counter like he’d always lived there. It was strange, but Theo almost seemed more comfortable in his skin than he had when he arrived, like being here and taking care of this house had given him some much needed confidence.
I insisted on helping with the dishes since Constance didn’t have a dishwasher. We stood side by side at the sink, him washing and me drying, and our arms brushed twice, and we both pretended not to notice. That didn’t keep my skin from tingling every time it happened.
“So,” Theo said, handing me the last plate. “I have a question.”
“Go ahead.”
“Did you actually want to come tonight, or did you come because I practically dared you to, and you’re not the kind of man who backs down from a dare?” His voice took on a flirty quality.
I met his eyes. “Both.”