Page 113
“A grand gesture?”
“Yes! Sorry, this is my grand gesture. I was supposed to ride up to you on a horse in Central Park today after brunch and sweep you off your feet but I would’ve had to transport the horse and drive on the right with a horse trailer and that seemed ill advised. It’s also February. Your friends said the horse thing is an abused tiny trope but they had never heard of a coconut trope.”
“You want to live in a grass hut with me?”
“Euphemistically, I suppose. Long term I would prefer a bed, but I would live anywhere as long as you were with me. Selling coconuts, anything really, seems like a good idea as long as you’re there with me.”
“You want to be with me?” he asks, incredulous. “Like with me, with me? In public?”
“Of course in public with you, how else would I show you off?” I say. “I want to be with you, Schuyler Sterling. I’m no expert on relationships, I’ve never had a real one, but I’m quite sure that having one would include going places together.”
I’ve badly misjudged everything.
I was sure he felt something for me, and his friends were convinced, but I’m on the back foot here. He’s neither irate nor thrilled, he’s… nothing. He’s a blank canvas. He closes his eyes, like he’s asking a higher power to deliver him from evil. He clenches his jaw so hard he’s putting his perfect teeth at risk as he rubs his temples like I’m the source of a massive headache.
After eons of painful silence, eyes still shut, he speaks. “You’re the future Duke of Canterbury, have you lost your fucking mind?” His voice is rough, as though he’s suffering greatly. And it’s not the declaration of love I had hoped for, but we have to start somewhere.
“I have not,” I say, a simple statement of fact. “This is me in absolute control of my life for the first time, and I’m here. For you, to be completely clear.”
“Becks, no. Absolutely not. This is the definition of insanity. You’re rich. You’re the future earl of some shit. You’re bisexual, and that means you can be just as happy with a woman as a man. Go be with a woman. I’m… not any of those things. I’m a regular guy. I don’t have anything to offer, no money, no title, no horse, no mansion.”
He looks like he’s injured, ready to cry out from the pain of it, and I’m the source of his suffering. “I’m not special, Becks. Not like you. Please, don’t do this. It won’t work but it’ll be enough to break my heart into so many pieces that I can never put it back together.” His eyes plead with me. “Please?”
I would give anything to hear him beg, but not like this. Still, there’s a glimmer of hope that mingles amongst the sadness in his eyes.
He can’t hide it.
He fell for me too.
This isn’t a fool’s errand.
There was an us. There was. I’ll never believe otherwise.
His eyes are cool, almost remote but they tell me everything. He’s terrified. He wraps his arms around himself in the balmy breeze in self defense, not from a chill. He oozes sorrow so thick and pungent that it makes my chest ache, and my throat tighten.
“I miss you so much, Schuyler.”
“You left me. Gone without a see you later, you flew off into the sunrise to marry a woman.” Sky’s shoulders slump, and his body wilts as the words tumble out, like his life force is escaping, leaving him deflated and his blue eyes flat.
“I’m sorry, Schuyler. I had to go back to become a man who might be good enough for you. I’ve walked away from everything to have a chance that you might want me too, to be free to live in a grass hut as long as you’re there with me. Preferably someone else would build it though because this one is a sad state of affairs.”
His eyes flit over the pathetic excuse for a grass hut. He doesn’t so much as smirk at my jest. “This is madness, Becks. For the rest of your life people will ask what you were thinking, why would you settle for someone like me? One day, you’ll resent me for everything you’ve given up.” He shakes his head, bitter but wistful. “Besides, what would your fiancée say?”
I’m happy—nay, eager—to clear this up. Despite my nerves, I say it firmly, without even a hint of waver in my voice. “I’m not engaged, nor have I ever been.”
“I saw the paper with my own eyes.”
“It was definitely in the newspaper but you saw an announcement my father made, it was never true. I’ve never asked anyone to marry me.” I have his attention now, his eyes are big, filled with surprise. “I’m as single as I’ve ever been, but my heart is spoken for.”
A fleeting upward tilt of his lips appears before he schools his expression. My Sky has no future as a poker player.
“I don’t want to be single. I want you. All I want is you, Schuyler.”
He continues like I didn’t say that essential last bit, but he heard it because he flinched. “Anyway, if I’m going to miss you I need that to start now,” he says, sad but firm. “Not after making more island memories.”
He steps back, warding off any attempt I might make to entice him back into my arms. “I can’t forget how you sound when I’m inside you and now I’ll be haunted by how stunning you are at sunset on a beach on Chaucer Cay. Falling in love with you and you leave again? I won’t survive that. I need to walk away now, while there’s still enough of my heart left to keep my job, and I can pretend people get happily ever after.” He lets out a long, sad sigh. “I’m begging you, Becks, please spare my battered heart and let me survive you.” His eyes well with tears, but none fall. Sadness is on him like a dark aura, pain duels the tiny flicker of hope he can’t hide.
I lean into that shard of painful hope.