Page 46
Nolan felt his jaw tighten instinctively, feeling immediately on the defensive. But he looked at Abigail, and all he saw was genuine kindness and curiosity in her eyes. She wasn’t picking at him or trying to push for something he didn’t want to talk about. He felt sure that if he told her he didn’t want to talk about it, she’d let it go. And that, strangely enough, made him want to open up.
“There is,” he admitted. “When I was a kid, my parents split up at Christmas. The day before, they sat me down and let me know that they were getting a divorce.” He let out a breath that frosted in the air in front of them. “I honestly to this day don’t know what they were thinking, picking that day, but I guess they just couldn’t handle pretending through another holiday. For the longest time, that was all the holiday made me think about—my parents splitting up and my mother being teary-eyed all through the holiday, and all the dread and unhappiness that it created. Christmases after that were always tight with money, and my mother was always stressed, and it was never really happy again, you know?”
He paused, realizing that Abigail hadn’t interrupted or tried to say or do anything other than just sit there, watching him sympathetically as she listened. And he hadn’t realized how much he’d appreciate that, someone who would just sit there and listen without an opinion or trying to fix it.
“As a kid, I guess it made all the Christmas joy and festivity seem fake. I started wondering how many other people were really unhappy or having a hard time or didn’t really want to celebrate, but were just doing it because they were supposed to. And all of this—” He waved a hand around the town, “—started feeling really performative and kind of ridiculous.”
He glanced over at Abigail. “But this year, I’ve actually enjoyed it… a little,” he added grudgingly. “And I have you to thank for that, so… thank you.”
“It’s my pleasure,” she said with a little laugh. “And I’m so sorry about your parents,” she added quickly, reaching over to squeeze his hand as her expression turned serious again. “That must have been so hard. It makes sense why all of the holly jolly merriment didn’t feel the same for you any longer. I’m glad you told me, though. And I’m glad it’s been a little better, this year.”
He’d thought it would be harder to talk about, actually. But sitting next to Abigail in the December cold, passing the box of peppermint bark back and forth, it had felt like a relief. Like he’d been waiting to find someone that he could finally open up to.
Her expression had relaxed, but he could tell that she was still going through something. There was some heartache that had brought her here that he wasn’t fully aware of, but he didn’t want to pry. He’d opened up to her, and if they had the chance, he was sure she’d do the same when she was ready.
But he wanted to see her smile again. More than anything, he wanted to cheer her up, and he knew he could. He’d certainly done it before.
An unexpected idea came to him as he finished off another piece of peppermint bark. He’d always avoided things like this because of all the memories it brought up, but so far he’d done plenty of things with Abigail this season that should have made him think of memories he’d rather forget. Instead, those things had just made him enjoy the holiday a little bit more.
“I want to show you something,” he said, glancing over at her. “If you’re up for it.”
Abigail looked up at him, curiosity replacing some of the sadness in her eyes. “What is it?”
“There’s a lookout point a little ways up the trail behind the town that overlooks all of it.” He smiled without thinking about it, and it didn’t feel bad at all. In fact, he felt like the idea could, once again, be something that might actually be fun. “It’s a little bit of a hike, but I promise it’ll be worth it. And it might help both of us feel a little better.”
Abigail studied him for a moment, then placed her hand in his and let him pull her to her feet. “Okay. I trust you.”
The statement startled him with how it made him feel. The town trusted him to deliver their mail and chop their firewood, but he didn’t have anyone close who trusted him, anyone who would look up at him wide-eyed and say that while going off to do something together. He hadn’t thought he missed it until right that second, when Abigail said those words.
“Come on,” he said, leading her toward his truck. “It’s a little bit of a drive.”
They climbed into his personal vehicle, a well-worn pickup that had seen better days but ran reliably. Nolan started the engine and pulled out onto the main road, heading toward the outskirts of town. Abigail sat quietly beside him, the box of peppermint bark in her lap, occasionally glancing at him with a curious expression, but without actually saying anything.
He’d driven the route out to the trail that led up to the lookout point countless times, but he hadn’t actually followed the trail up to it since before his parents had split up. All it did was remind him of when they’d been together, when they’d all been a happy, normal family, and nothing had been wrong.
But that had all been a long time ago. And now, he wanted to make Abigail smile more than he wanted to avoid thinking about the past.
So he drove, reaching the trailhead, he parked and glanced over at Abigail.
“Ready?” he asked, and she nodded, already smiling.
That made it all worth it before they’d even gotten out of the truck.
CHAPTER NINETEEN
Nolan came around to open her door, and Abigail set the box of peppermint bark on the seat as she slid out, suppressing a gasp at how cold it was. The temperature had dropped a good bit even during the short drive, but she was so curious about what Nolan wanted to show her that she didn’t mind.
Normally she wouldn’t have gone out hiking in the dark with a near-stranger, but she really did trust him. Everything about him made her feel as if he were a safe, warm, good person to be with, to be around. And if he said he had something that would cheer them both up, she trusted that he was telling the truth.
Even though they didn’t know each other that well, he seemed to know what would make her smile. It was a trait that she hadn’t realized how much she’d appreciate until she’d met him.
She pulled her coat tighter around herself and followed Nolan up the trail. The ground was uneven, patches of ice gleaming in the faint light from the truck’s interior. She took a careful step, then another, but her boot hit a slick patch and she felt herself start to slide. Before she could stumble, Nolan’s hand was on her arm, warm and solid, keeping her from tripping.
“Careful,” he said, his voice concerned. “It’s icy up here.”
Abigail suddenly felt very warm, despite the frigid chill of the evening. When she didn’t pull away, he kept his hand gently on her arm, helping her stay steady as they made their way up the hill. She didn’t mind it one bit. Especially every time his arm flexed when he helped steady her, reminding her that he was more than a bit muscular from all the walking and chopping firewood he did.
“Thank you,” she managed, her voice coming out breathier than she’d intended.