AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Christmas With The Wrong Brother

Page 120

by Vitina Rose

But my answer comes too quickly.

Colleen looks toward the pond. “Hank and I spent the first year of our marriage deciding what the other person could handle. He hid dangerous calls at work because he didn’t want me worrying. I hid how much the waiting scared me because I didn’t want him feeling guilty.”

“That sounds considerate.”

“It was nearly fatal.”

I look at her.

“Not literally,” she adds. “Although I did consider killing him after I learned he’d been inside a grain silo fire while I was home making lasagna.”

A laugh escapes me.

“My point is, we weren’t protecting each other. We were controlling each other’s reactions because honesty felt harder.” She nudges my arm with hers.

The lantern grows heavy in my hand.

Celeste’s face flashes through my mind.

Maverick still has no idea Carter was sleeping with his former fiancée—or what I overheard them talking about before I left.

“What if the truth isn’t yours alone?” I ask carefully. “What if telling someone would hurt them, and keeping it quiet seems… kinder?”

Colleen is silent long enough that I hear skates scraping the pond and a child laughing near the fire.

“Is the silence kinder for them,” she asks, “or safer for you?”

The question slips through every excuse I’ve built.

I told myself Maverick did not need another Hawthorne disaster to solve. That Carter’s betrayal was my humiliation, my wound, my choice to bury. That revealing Celeste’s part would force Maverick to relive an engagement that had already ended years ago.

All of that is true.

It’s also true that I do not want to see Maverick’s face when he learns I knew his former fiancée had been sleeping with his own brother—and that the two of them had been plotting to destroy him long before he walked away from everything himself.

I do not want him wondering why I kept it from him while sleeping in his bed.

I do not want his anger, his hurt, or the possibility that he’ll look at me and decide my silence makes me one more person who managed him instead of trusted him.

So I’ve been waiting for the right moment.

Except the right moment is what I called every month I postponed asking Carter why he no longer touched me.

Sometimes waiting is patience.

Sometimes it’s fear.

“If he learns it from someone else,” Colleen says gently, “you won’t have spared him the pain. You’ll only have made sure the truth didn’t come from you.”

Across the snow, Maverick straightens with two pairs of skates hanging from one hand.

His eyes find mine immediately.

My chest tightens.

He and Hank start toward us.

Hank lifts his radio before they reach us. “Weather service says another system may arrive Wednesday night. Too early to know whether it’ll graze the mountain or sit on us.”