Page 56
“You didn’t hand him anything,” Seth said.
Alyvia looked over at him.
“Alyvia, you went out with your friends. You didn’t do anything wrong.”
The words settled somewhere deep, and Alyvia turned back toward the water.
“But I knew there was a possibility he could be in town.” She shook her head. “John wasn’t always a bad person.”
She wasn’t sure why she needed Seth to know that, but she did.
“When we got married, he was different. He was funny and attentive, and he could make me feel like I was the only person in a room. I loved him. My family loved him.” She swallowed. “Then he came home from his last deployment, and something had changed.”
Alyvia explained how the nightmares started first, followed by the mood swings and anger. She told Seth about researching PTSD and finding doctors, programs, and counselors. She had offered to go with John to appointments or sit outside if he didn’t want her in the room. She had done everything she could think of, but John refused to admit he needed help.
The verbal abuse came first, followed by holes punched in walls, broken dishes, and doors slammed hard enough to crack frames. Eventually it became grabbing her hard enough to leave bruises and shoving her when she tried to walk away. Alyvia hid all of it, convincing herself that if she could just get him help, the man she had married would come back.
“The last night was different. It was the first Friday of the month. Some girlfriends and I had this standing thing where we would go out for dinner and drinks once a month. We had been doing it forever.” She rubbed her thumb across the condensation on her bottle. “John knew where I was. It wasn’t a secret. He had never cared about it before.”
She paused and tried to breathe through the pressure building in her chest.
“When I got home, he was drunk. I remember walking inside and knowing immediately that something was wrong. He was sitting in the dark with a bottle on the coffee table, and I had barely gotten my purse off my shoulder before he started accusing me of staying out too late.”
Alyvia’s fingers began trembling around the bottle.
“He wanted to know who I’d been with and whether there had been men there. I told him it was the same women I always went out with, but he wouldn’t listen. The more I tried to calm him down, the angrier he got. Eventually, I tried to walk away because by then I’d learned arguing only made things worse, but he grabbed me and threw me against the wall hard enough that my head hit it. I don’t remember everything after that clearly because the doctors said I had a concussion, but I remember enough. He ripped my shirt when I tried to get away from him. He hit me, punched me, slapped me. Every time I tried to get up, he’d knock me down again.”
The first tear slipped down her cheek, and Alyvia wiped it away.
“I don’t know why I said it. Maybe I finally realized I wasn’t going to survive if I stayed. I told him I hated him, and I told him I was leaving him.”
Her voice cracked. “He had a knife.”
Alyvia's free hand moved instinctively toward her stomach.
“He cut me across here.” She traced the area over her shirt, and Seth’s gaze followed the movement.
“There was so much blood. I remember looking down and seeing it everywhere, and I think that finally broke through whatever was happening in his head because he just stopped. He looked at me, dropped the knife, and ran.”
The tears came faster now. “I don’t remember calling nine-one-one. But apparently, I did. The next thing I really remember is waking up in the hospital. I was there for several days. I had a concussion, broken ribs, cuts, bruising around one of my kidneys, and I had lost enough blood that they were worried about me for a while.”
Alyvia wiped at her face again, frustrated that she couldn’t make the tears stop.
“My parents came. My brother and sisters came. When I got out of the hospital, I never went back to that house alone. I filed for divorce, and as soon as I could, I left North Dakota.”
Her voice broke completely as she looked at Seth.
“I’ve been hiding from him ever since.”
Seth had killed men before. He had done it in places Alyvia would never know about, under circumstances he would never be able to discuss with her, and because it was his job.
Right now, he wanted to kill John for entirely personal reasons.
He sat perfectly still because if he allowed himself to react the way every cell in his body wanted to, he would be in his truck and halfway back to the bar before Alyvia realized he had left.
The son of a bitch had beaten her, thrown her into a wall, torn her clothes, and then taken a knife to her.
And the sweet woman sitting beside him was crying as though she still needed to justify why she had run.