AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 68

by Ariana Kemp

I tried to think through it from her perspective as I took in exaggerated breath, exhaling through my mouth, the air gently blowing her bangs out of her eyes. Whether or not she was aware of it, she was matching my cadence.

I was sure it had looked scary as I fell off the roof, but I caught myself . . . sort of. There wasn’t any blood on me. I hadn’t hit my head. I was laughing and smiling right after.

I had seen her deal with some gruesome injuries with a level head and not a trace of panic. So what was it?

My mind flipped through all of the little moments lately where I caught her staring off, her shoulders curling as if she was carrying some heavy weight. Whenever her eyes met mine though, she perked right up, back to her usual bubbly self. Was this a glimpse of what was actually going on inside her head? If so, goodness.

Lord, help me to help her.

“I’m safe, Winifred. I’m right here,” I soothed, softer this time as her breathing incrementally slowed.

“You could have died,” she repeated, her words stronger this time, her eyes glinting as she shoved at my chest.

Good. I would take her anger over terror.

“But I didn’t,” I offered a small smile and she squeezed my wrists, her brow furrowing.

“What were you thinking, Cohen?” she hissed, letting go to gesture to the roof. “What if you had fallen on your head? There wouldn’t be any coming back from that. And for what? A stupid roof?”

“I just slipped, Win. It was an accident. It could have happened to anyone.” I let my hands slide down to rest on her shoulders, squeezing lightly to try and relieve some of the tension there. “I’m okay.”

It was then that she seemed to fully come back to her senses, her gaze tracking to the other men surrounding us. Her cheeks grew red and the column of her throat tightened as she swallowed.

In a split second though, she pasted on her usual smile, running her palms over my chest as if she was smoothing my shirt. It was like a switch flipped, and it was unsettling.

“I’m so sorry for losing it on you,” she blurted out. “I’m glad you’re okay. I have some cookies in the oven I need to check on.”

She pulled away from me and stood on wobbly legs before I could stop her.

“Wait, are you alright?” I asked, moving to stand, but she pressed against my shoulder, shaking her head with what I was beginning to realize was a practiced smile.

“I’m fine,” she reassured before turning on her heel and fleeing.

I gaped as she nearly ran away to her cabin.

That was not the Winifred I knew. Seeing this side of her felt strangely intimate, like something that I wanted to be for my eyes alone instead of surrounded by my friends.

I rubbed at my sternum, replaying that image of her over and over in my head. Something wasn’t right.

I’m fine. Her words echoed through my mind.

She most decidedly did not sound fine. She sounded like she wanted to be—like maybe she even believed her own words—but now that I had seen that look in her eyes, I couldn’t unsee it.

Winifred was a lot of things, but she was not fine.

17

WINIFRED

“Climbing.” Cohen’s voice carried through the valley.

“Climb on,” Shepherd grunted.

Who in their right mind would climb the side of a mountain for fun?

After the roof incident a few weeks ago, this seemed like the absolute worst idea in the history of man, but Cohen insisted that it wasn’t only safe, but “fun.”

I had my doubts.