AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 39

by Ariana Kemp

“Well, Winnie, it was a pleasure meeting you.” Adler nodded to me, glancing at Cohen as his smile grew. “We’ll see you this evening, and you can expect us to be regular fixtures in your shop. We’ll catch you later, man. Take your time.”

He turned and walked out of the shop, Shepherd trailing behind before he hesitated at the door, turning back to me as he clutched his pastry box.

“Any friend of Cohen’s is a friend of ours,” he grunted. “You need anything and this one isn’t answering, you come get us.”

It wasn’t a question, it was more of a statement.

“Thank you, Shepherd. I appreciate that,” I said genuinely.

The man nodded once before striding out the door after his buddy, a small whistle causing the dogs to follow right on his heel.

I grinned and shook my head at the interaction. He was one odd cookie—all of the men were, really.

Adler: the flirty cowboy with watchful eyes that was at odds with his sweet talking persona.

Shepherd: the grumpy lumberjack who looked like a grizzly, though I was pretty sure was a big ol’ teddy bear with a thorn in his paw.

And Cohen—my cheeks heated at the thought of him—the kind and perceptive man with a familiarity that unnerved me. It was like an old friend had moved to town and we were picking up right where we left off.

“Whatcha thinkin’ there, Win?” Cohen’s deep chuckle shocked me out of my ruminations, and my face warmed further at being caught secretly salivating over him as if he wasn’t even there.

“Um, lemon bars?” I winced at how high and squeaky my voice sounded.

Lemon bars? Really?

“Lemon bars, huh?” He grinned, leaning against the counter to lower his voice, as if he didn’t want someone to hear. “Must have been some good lemon bars.”

Was this flirting? Was he flirting with me? My knees weakened at the thought.

“The best,” I squeaked, clearing my throat and scurrying away to the other counter to grab a small parchment bag I’d already prepared. “For you! I mean, I set this aside for you this morning. You liked the apple pie last night. This is that in macaroon form. I’ll broaden your pastry palette yet!”

“I’m sure it’s amazing.” He grinned. “Thank you, Win.” His expression grew a bit more thoughtful and his Adam’s apple bobbed as he mulled over his next words.

“Thank you for being kind to Shepherd,” he settled on, those perceptive eyes trained intently on me. “He’s been through a lot, and he has a really hard time being social.”

“It was my pleasure, Cohen,” I said softly, a corner of my mouth titling up. “Your friends are super nice. I’m looking forward to meeting the rest of them.”

“You might take that back after tonight,” he laughed, eyes twinkling. “Everyone together can be a handful. Does six thirty still work for you?”

“Sounds perfect.”

“I won’t be able to stop by this evening to help close since I’ll be planning with the others, but can I bring you some dinner from Lettie’s? Pastrami burger or Caesar wrap?” he asked kindly as he reached out to snag a toothpick from the dispenser on the counter and nestled it between his entirely too perfect teeth. The fact that he knew my order had my heart thumping in my chest, panic and attraction warring against each other.

“Oh, you don’t have to do that,” I said quickly. “Really. I’m fine.”

Cohen’s head tilted to the side as he scanned my features. He casually slipped his hands into his front pockets, his gaze soft.

“I know I don’t have to,” he agreed, leaning his hip against the counter. “And I also know you have the big Patterson order that you’re prepping tonight.” Butterflies erupted in my stomach at his words—he had actually listened to me when I had mentioned that a couple of days ago. “It has also come to my attention that you, my dear Winifred, are prone to forgetting to look after yourself when you’re doing something you love. So I’ll ask again, fully aware that I don’t have to do anything, but I want to take care of you—pastrami burger or Caesar wrap?”

My breath caught in my chest, my eyes locked on Cohen’s as we both stood in silence, my racing heart beginning to slow incrementally.

I couldn’t stand other people taking care of me. I had lived my life shutting people down whenever they offered, but Cohen didn’t even give me a chance to say no. He was patient, yet persistent in a way that slid right past my defenses.

This past week had challenged me in ways I hadn’t expected, yet had also been so very sweet. Because while I hated the thought of letting others take care of me, every time Cohen went out of his way to do something for me, it caused a little piece of my soul to quiet. To rest.

And I don’t know what to do in the silence.

The admission had my throat tightening with emotion.