Page 35
“Did you know, there’s this baker girl that I’m absolutely taken by?”
“Oh, you don’t have to do this,” I started, my words tapering off as he slowly raised a calloused thumb to wipe a smudge of flour from my bangs.
“She loves God so fiercely, with the same persistence she brings into every area of her life. She has this sparkle in her eyes and this grace to her movements that’s captivating. But you want to know the best part?”
I couldn’t find words even if I tried, so I simply nodded.
Cohen leaned in ever so closer, whispering: “she knows butterflies.”
“Cohen,” I whispered, his name rolling off my tongue so softly that it sounded like an endearment.
“Mornin’, sugar,” he drawled softly, only for my ears before squeezing my hand and stepping backwards, releasing it. He turned his attention to Lettie who was watching intently, back straight and gaze zeroed in on our interaction.
“Nice to see you again, Lettie,” Cohen smiled, giving her a small nod of greeting. “Your day going okay so far?”
“It’s been good. You plan on murdering my girl here? Or catfishing her with this whole country boy drawl you’ve got going on?” Lettie said without a moment’s hesitation.
My face burned from my cheeks to the tips of my ears.
“Leticia,” I hissed, stepping forward as if I could somehow physically stop her from talking.
“She’s fine, Win,” Cohen grinned, his gaze fixed on Lettie. “I appreciate you looking out for her, Lettie. No, I don’t plan on murdering or catfishing her. I really admire Winifred and enjoy spending time with her. Lord willing and Winifred permitting, I’d like to explore where our relationship leads.”
My jaw went slack at his straightforward admission, Lettie slowly grinning in approval.
“Good.” She nodded. “Treat her right or the sheriff will never find your body.”
“I’d expect nothing less.”
“Is this the Lettie who owns the bar you talked about, Cohen?” One of the two men behind him stepped forward and I tried not to grimace, knowing how this was about to end. If a loud and belligerent man stumbled into Lettie’s bar, she was as cool as a cucumber. The light and friendly tone this handsome man was using, though? This wouldn’t be pretty.
“It is, indeed,” Cohen looked like he was holding back a smile as his friend turned his attention directly to Lettie.
“This one says your place serves the best burger he’s ever had. That’s high praise coming from him,” he started, opening his mouth to continue, but Lettie cut him off.
“Flattery will get you nowhere, big guy,” she snapped, standing up and snagging a free cookie off the top of my display case. “Just stop while you’re ahead.”
“Who said I was flatterin’?” the man chuckled, his lips tipping up in a charming smile. “I’ve never been to your bar. The food could be awful for all I know. I was simply going to ask when you open for dinner. We need somewhere to eat tonight and a burger sounds good. If it’s good, then I’ll try my hand at flatterin’ you.”
Lettie opened her mouth to respond before quickly shutting it, narrowing her eyes at him.
He smirked in return.
“We open at four,” she growled, flitting gracefully out of the room like a departing storm cloud carried by a tempest wind.
I turned my attention to Cohen’s friend to apologize, but the man was watching after her, a small smile on his lips.
“I like her,” he said simply.
I met Cohen’s gaze and we both tried to stifle our smiles at the interaction. Lettie’s beauty reminded me of a Siren. It drew men to her without fail, but she’d ruthlessly dash them upon the metaphorical rocks if they so much as looked at her in a way that suggested they were interested.
I turned to Cohen’s friends, who still respectfully stood by the entrance as if they didn’t want to crowd Cohen and me.
“You’re all so far away! Come introduce yourselves and I’ll see if I can pin down what type of pastry men you are.”
The men stepped forward, both carrying themselves with the same casual air that Cohen had about him. It made my heart warm. They were obviously trying to make me feel as comfortable as possible and while it wasn’t needed, it was appreciated all the same.
“Welcome to Burch Creek. I’m Winifred, but you can call me Winnie,” I said warmly, my hands nervously smoothing my daisy apron. “We’re happy to have you guys in town. What you’re all doing is wonderful.”