AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Baked with Love

Page 15

by Ariana Kemp

My phone buzzed where I had set it on the counter, and I glanced at the screen.

The room tilted for a split second, and I bit the inside of my cheek to suppress the whimper that was trying to claw its way from my throat.

Sheriff Carter.

Could I not have one night this week without something going terribly wrong? I was exhausted, and was in no position to help with SAR work at the moment.

When did that ever matter, though?

When did I matter?

Lord, help. I couldn’t manage anything else. My heart reached for words to communicate just how I felt, and I couldn’t drum up anything else.

Just, help.

I carefully schooled my features, trying to maintain my happy composure as I looked back at Cohen. Those perceptive eyes though, so keen and watchful, were assessing me yet again, concern creeping into his expression.

“Okay?”

“Yeah, I’m good.” I forced some pep into my tone and gave a smile for good measure. “I have to take this. I’m so sorry. I’ll see you tomorrow?”

“Looking forward to it,” he confirmed, his smile slowly slipping away for the first time since he had strode into my shop. Without that smile? He was . . . intense. Maybe even borderline intimidating. I felt like an exposed wire under his watchful gaze as I looked away and shifted from foot to foot, my fingers tangling in my apron.

“Are you sure you’re okay, Winnie?”

Amidst my anxiety, my stomach did a pleasant little flip. That was the first time he’d called me by my nickname, and it had a certain ring to it coming from him.

“I’m good, Cohen,” I reassured softly, picking up my phone as it started ringing for a second time in a row. If I didn’t answer this time, the sheriff would end up on my doorstep. I knew this pattern well. “I’ll see you tomorrow. Thank you again for all your help. I really appreciate it.”

He slowly nodded, pausing before snagging a purple napkin and sharpie off the counter. He scrawled a phone number on it and slid it forward, rapping a knuckle on the counter twice.

“Have a good night,” he said kindly, pointing to the napkin. “I know I’m a stranger and all, but you call me if you need anything, yeah? Day or night.”

His words washed over me, warming parts of me that had long since felt cold and lonely. The way he looked at me, really looked at me when he said those words with such sincerity, had me believing that he meant it.

He sent a small wink my way, easily picking up his donut and drink in one hand and placing a twenty-dollar bill in the tip jar with his other. With a little two-finger wave, he turned around and strode out of my shop with that same purpose to his steps that he walked in with.

My phone rang for a third time, and I sighed sharply, drawing on every iota of patience I had before accepting the call.

“There you are. I was just about to head over your way. Someone reported a tourist missing. Last his family heard, he was hiking the Boneyard. Think you could maybe . . .”

“I’ll be there in twenty.”

5

COHEN

“If I take another bite of food, I might just keel over right where I’m sitting,” I groaned, leaning back against the worn leather booth. Dim overhead lights and a single stained-glass lamp over each table made the entire bar and grill feel homey. The place was humming with conversation, some old-school country music playing quietly beneath it all. Bruno had been entirely right in his rave reviews of this hole-in-the-wall restaurant.

“I think that might be the best burger I’ve ever had.”

“Don’t I know it.” The elderly man chuckled, taking a sip of his water before slowly shifting forward to rest his elbows on the table, his hands folded and eyes trained on me.

I grinned at his blatant staring. In the half-day I had known this man, I quickly realized that while his body may have slowed down, his mind was as sharp as a tack. There wasn’t much he seemed to miss.

“So, would you like the number of my real estate agent?” he asked point-blank.

“Pardon?”