AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

On the Fly

Page 110

by S.J. Crawford

“If I’m out of line, stop me, but…” He sucks in a breath. “I like you.”

Relief washes over me. Whatever the complete opposite to out of line is, he’s that.

Onside? Inline? I don’t know. Who cares?

“Really? I couldn’t tell.” I lift my shirt like a douche, giving us both an out just in case.

“Not just physically.” He snickers and yanks my shirt back down, poking my chest with his other hand. “I like you.”

The smile spreading across my face isn’t one I could stop if I tried. “Same here. You’re pretty great.”

“Aw.” He averts his tired eyes and claps his hands together again, pursing his lips in a way that’s endearing as fuck. “I couldn’t help myself, to be honest. You’re so good to me, and I feel…I don’t know. You make me feel special for being me, not because of what I do.”

He’s being so earnest, and I don’t know what to do with it. “Only ‘cause you make it easy. You’re a good”—friend—“guy.”

He smiles at that, and it could be me being idealistic, but a small glimmer of hope shines in my stomach. Caleb’s softness, combined with what he’s saying, could be the precursor for…

Being more.

The idea hooks into my defenseless brain, and if I don’t get confirmation in either direction soon, I’m gonna fall even harder.

“Did you come back early just to confess you like me?” I don’t want to get ahead of myself, but I’m hoping he doesn’t beat around the bush much longer.

“It’ll be hard, I know, and I’m scared of being selfish,” he says, “but I really want to ask if…you want to be, like, together.”

Holy shit.

Holy. Fucking. Shit.

I don’t have words. I reach out and haul his body into mine, toppling us both backward. We chuckle at each other, our faces mere centimeters apart. When we’re this close, I don’t have a choice but to kiss him.

“Abso-fucking-lutely,” I eke out, pulling back just enough to speak. “Why were you even nervous? I’m so into you, I’m losing my mind.”

He sighs, still smiling, but there’s still a trace of disbelief clinging to his expression.

“Because nothing else has changed. I’m not ready to come out publicly, I don’t know when I will be, and I don’t want to drag you into that mess.”

Every piece of advice out there says not to date a closeted guy, especially when there’s no end date. But that advice doesn’t hold true if both guys need to stay subtle.

“Sure,” I get out, “as long as you’re fine with me not being super open, too.”

“What’s stopping you?”

“My dad’s”—batshit insane—“got some messed-up views, and it’s best if I don’t rock the boat even more before both Jess—my sister—and I are both independent.”

“Jesus, it’s that bad?”

“Yeah. Jess still lives with him, and I still want to talk to her. And my tuition and stuff are covered by a trust he owns half of.”

Going to court over it would be a hassle, even if I’d probably win.

Caleb sits up, crossing his legs and putting a hand on my thigh. It’s supposed to be soothing, but all it does is make my heart go wild. “I’m sorry.”

I shake my head. “It’s fine. I don’t want to trouble you with my weird family, so don’t worry. We’ll just have to be⁠—”

“A secret.”

“Private,” I correct. “And if you think about it, does anyone else on the team have a super high-profile relationship?”