Page 96
Shit! This is bad.
“Wrenlee Reed.”
She gasps and cries out. “Wren?”
The way she says my name, like she knows me, makes everything inside me pause. Please let it be her. At least she’d be alive. “Leslie?”
“Yes!” she bursts out.
“Thank god,” I breathe out, ignoring the fact that now we’re both trapped. “Where are we?”
“I’m pretty sure it’s a basement.” Her voice trembles.
Fear of being kept in the dark without any source of light is terrifying. An infinite nothing pressing in from every direction. My mind spirals. Something could be inches from my face right now and I’d never know.
A shiver crawls up my spine, and I pull my feet up under me.
“Are you tied up too?” I’m assuming she’s been here since she went missing three days ago. “Does anyone ever come down? Is it always pitch dark?” The questions spill out faster than she can answer them.
She sniffs. “There are metal poles that run up the walls. That’s what we’re tied to. I wasn’t tied up before. He…he tied me up right before he brought you in.”
I swallow hard, my throat feeling like I swallowed dust.
“The lights were on when I woke up here. There’s a bathroom in the corner. But he turned them off that day and didn’t turn them back on until today. There are steps that come down, which is why I think it’s a basement.”
“He? Do you know who it is?”
“No. Whenever he’s come down, he’s worn a mask.”
Did you fight? Try to get away?
The questions press against the back of my throat. I hate myself for even thinking it. Of course she fought.
“I’m sorry about your brother,” she whispers, her voice cracking. “I never meant for him to get involved…” Her voice trails off.
“It’s not your fault.” Tears sting my eyes. “Once he heard about your letter, there’s no way he would’ve—”
“Wait, what letter?” she asks, interrupting me.
What letter? The letter that started all of this.
“The letter you sent Keaton,” I say slowly.
“I didn’t send a letter to anyone. Your brother showed up on my doorstep one day…asking questions. I just wanted to forget everything.”
How did he find Leslie? I don’t think he talked to Chloe, so when did her name come up?
“Brody wrote in his notes that you were ready to tell him everything. That was right before he died.”
“Yeah. I…” She pauses. “I have proof of something that happened in high school. To me. And I always wondered if that person killed Keaton’s dad.” Her voice quivers. “I was going to give it to Brody. I was finally ready to go to the police.”
Even though I spent years in jail because she held on to this information, my heart still hurts for her. What she went through was horrible.
“Did you go to Keaton’s party right before graduation?” She sniffs.
“No.” I want to tell her I already know so she doesn’t have to relive it by saying it out loud, but she’ll wonder how. She’ll be mortified knowing Chloe was in the closet.
“I wish I wasn’t there.” Her voice breaks. “I was raped that night.”