Page 90
“Since first grade.”
I blink. “Bullshit.”
“You had finished playing the piano for the talent show. I remember sitting there, completely amazed by you. Then when Brody made some smart-ass comment only an asshole brother could say, you marched over and whacked him over the head, spun on your heels, and sat down like nothing happened.”
I remember that day. Brody was jealous I was getting attention for once. He was the one always front and center, and his made-up-on-the-spot magic act, which was him being ridiculous on stage, didn’t get the reaction he’d expected.
“That’s what did it, huh? Hitting my brother?”
He shrugs one shoulder. “I was six. My standards were different.”
I smack his chest. He catches my hand, kissing the palm.
“But the way you lit up when I called you Winnie, I never wanted to call you by anything else.”
Heat creeps into my cheeks. “So, you’re saying you’ve liked me since first grade?”
His expression softens. “I have.”
For a beat, I struggle with the revelation, but I shove away the regret forming. I can’t go backward and change any of it. Instead, I force out another question.
“Why were you so mad?” I murmur. It’s the wound that never healed.
He drops his head with a groan and buries his face in my neck. “I was never mad at you. I was pissed at myself.”
“Why?”
His chest rises and falls before he lifts up again. He shifts off to the side, propping himself on his elbow, and brushes a strand of hair behind my ear. “If you were anybody but Brody’s sister…” His words trail off.
“So, you were mad because you had sex with your best friend’s sister?”
“No. I was mad because you deserved better than me for your first time. Especially how it happened.”
I chuckle. “As I recall, I’m the one who threw myself at you.”
“And I’m the one who should have walked away.”
Like I should’ve an hour ago.
Don’t freak out. It’s temporary.
We’re two people enjoying each other’s company. There is nothing wrong with that. People do it every day. Two normal people who have needs. I wait for the lie to sound like the truth, because we are not two normal people. We have history. And no amount of lying to myself will change that.
His finger resumes its lazy path along my arm again, and I close my eyes, trying to silence my inner voice. I startle when Keaton jerks his finger away and bolts upright. His body goes rigid, eyes scanning the room as if a switch just flipped.
“I smell smoke,” he says, already pushing off the covers.
My heart stutters. “What—”
The alarms explode to life.
I can’t move, my nightmare snapping to life. This isn’t happening, not again. Keaton’s already moving, pulling on a pair of jeans and rushing over to a chest, yanking it open and tossing out a few blankets.
“Move, Wrenlee!”
A flicker of orange light flashes through the window.
The house is on fire.