Page 85
So far, he’s proving my point. He is a dick. I sit on the edge of the couch, biting back my smirk.
Her eyes narrow to slits. “It’s okay.” She pauses, switching gears. “Speaking of that, when did you find out? About me and Keaton.”
The line goes silent for a moment, and she looks over at me, frowning.
“That night,” he finally admits. “I forgot my keys, and when I ran back inside, I overheard you guys in the bathroom.”
Wrenlee’s eyes widen, color rushing onto her cheeks.
“Did you tell anyone?” she asks.
“Of course not,” he stammers. “Yeah, I’m coming,” he shouts to someone. “Hey, Wren, can we talk later?”
“Yeah.”
“I’m working the graveyard shift, so I’ll call tomorrow?”
“That sounds good. Be careful out there,” she says.
“Always.”
The call disconnects, and silence floods the room.
She stands up and leans against the piano, wrapping her arms around herself. “He didn’t do it if that’s what you’re thinking.”
I lift my hands up. “I’m not thinking anything.”
Which is complete bullshit.
I don’t know what to make of him knowing, but he’s the connection we were searching for moments ago. And judging by the tension in her shoulders, she’s coming to the same conclusion. She pads over to the whiteboard, uncaps a marker, and scribbles Levi’s name across it. Underneath, she writes what she learned, ending with a giant question mark.
“So what if he found out beforehand?” She tosses the marker in the tray. “He only had that information for, what, a day and a half before the entire town found out? That doesn’t make him guilty.”
I see the war in her eyes.
“Why would he come back here if he did it? If he got away with the perfect crime?”
“Listen, I’m not saying he did it,” I say, pushing up to my feet and crossing my arms. “But it’s the same reason people who start fires return to the scene to volunteer to help. It’s a narcissistic personality where they want to be seen as the hero. They’re manipulative. Egotistical. Always chasing validation and attention.”
“And you believe that’s Levi?”
Yes.
She ponders, chewing on the inside of her cheek while her gaze drifts to the board. She exhales shakily. “I need air,” she says and storms out to the deck.
That woman will never trust anyone again. Giving her space, I grab my phone and order us pizza for dinner. She needs one night of mental disengagement. Earlier, she mentioned a show on Prime about some hockey players.
Sounds painfully girly.
But whatever will help her relax, I’m game.
CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN
Wrenlee
My eyes fly open to a pitch-black room.
“Hello?” I whisper.