Page 148
Aria’s eyes fill with tears again.
“You have two incredible parents who love you more than anything in this world. You got a childhood I would’ve never been able to give you from a prison cell. And as much as it hurt to miss so much of it, I never regretted giving you to them.”
My fingers itch to reach out and hug her again and somehow make all this hurt less, but I can see the pain in her eyes.
“You just knew. This entire time.” Her voice cracks as she hiccups, dropping her hands to her side. “Everyone knew, but me.”
Her trust is broken. And I’ll have to earn it back if she lets me.
“I know,” I whisper.
I want to tell her we were protecting her, or we thought we were doing the right thing, but I just let her be angry. Nothing I say will fix this.
Lucas reaches for her, gently squeezing her shoulder. She shrugs him off. “I know you all meant well, but this is a lot for me.”
Everyone in the room wants the same thing. To reach for her. To hold her. Beg her for forgiveness. Instead, we all stand back and give her space.
Her eyes find mine again. “I just want you to know that I understand the why.”
Then she turns and walks out of the house. We watch her open the back seat of the car and climb inside.
I suck in the cry that wants to escape. “I’m so sorry,” I whisper.
Mia walks over and wraps her arms around my waist. “Wrenlee, she loves you. She’s hurt. But we knew this day would be hard.”
She’s right. I hold on to what Aria said after Keaton’s joke. I kind of look like you. The acceptance is in there. It’s just buried under the hurt, confusion, and betrayal.
And she did hug me when she got here.
It takes Aria two weeks to call us. She called to see if we’d take her to the zoo. Of course, Keaton is beside himself. To say that man loves going to the zoo with Aria is an understatement. We’ve been more than a dozen times over the last few years, and every single time, I leave embarrassed because the two of them are absolutely ridiculous.
Mia pulls into the drop-off lane and waves. She and Lucas decided it would be best if Aria hung out with us alone. Aria’s been struggling with guilt. Like wanting to spend time with us somehow means she’s choosing us over them. So, Lucas and Mia made the choice for her. They want her to understand there’s room for all of us.
“Hey, monkey,” Keaton calls out when she walks up to us.
Her smile grows bigger. “Hey, trash panda.” She walks straight into his arms for a quick hug.
I hold my breath. I wasn’t expecting that. Keaton winks at me like he’s got this. Aria steps back and turns to me. For a fleeting second, I worry she won’t forgive me. Only Keaton. I mean, he didn’t even know about her until four years ago.
But then she hugs me, too. “Hi, Wren,” she says as if everything is normal.
The day couldn’t have gone better. She was full of surprises. I wondered if she was going to ignore the elephant in the room, but while walking toward the monkey enclosures, she asked us about our families. Her questions were nonstop after that. What were we like growing up? What are our parents like? She even asked how long we dated in high school.
Okay, so apparently some lies are allowed.
We told her we had dated for about a year but did not add any details. She’s at an impressionable age where she’s starting to like boys. There are certain parts about her parents’ teenage relationship, or lack thereof, that she does not need to hear about.
Maybe when she’s thirty. Or never.
I’m good with never.
By the time we leave the zoo, my face hurts from laughing. The two crazies ahead of me are walking like monkeys, complete with swinging arms and obnoxious noises that have everyone staring as we walk out the exit.
It’s in that moment I realize everything will be okay.
We drop Aria off at home after dinner. She slides out of the back seat but stops with one foot out the door. She turns to me. “You’re still doing my piano lessons, right?”
“Of course! I’ll see you Thursday. Don’t forget we’re at the new house.”