Page 131
I’m afraid to say anything.
Finally, he turns and heads toward me. I hold my breath when he bends down and picks his hat off the floor. He puts it on and stares at the door. This is it. He’s leaving. He’s about to walk out and never talk to me again.
“Can I see her?” he murmurs.
The words don’t register right away. My mind stutters, scrambling to catch up to what he asked. A flurry of panic tickles the pit of my stomach. See her? As in…meet her?
He points to the thing I’m about to crush in my arms. “I mean…pictures,” he clarifies, reading the anxiety attack I’m on the verge of having.
“Oh,” I clip, sucking in a much-needed breath. “Yes. Yes, of course.”
He walks over and sits on the couch. I sit beside him, leaving a good few inches between us. I open the album to the first page—her birth—and place it on his lap.
The second his eyes land on her, his breath hitches. His shoulders shudder. Tears spill between the two of us as he presses a hand to his mouth. I lean back, watching him flip from page to page, falling in love with his daughter. Or hating me even more.
“She doesn’t look like either of us,” he whispers, studying a picture when she was three. “She’s the perfect mix. Your beautiful eyes. My smile. But then she has dimples. Where did those come from?”
I sniff. “Brody had dimples.”
He shifts his weight toward me. “He didn’t know about her, did he?”
“No.” A sob rips out of me. I dab my eyes with the tissue. “There were so many times I wanted to tell him. And now it’s too late.”
He reaches over, wiping my tears away with his thumb. I lean into his touch before I can stop myself. A touch I never thought I’d feel again. His fingers slide under my chin, lifting it until our eyes meet.
“You did what you had to do,” he says.
My eyes flutter. How can he be so understanding? I keep bracing for the moment everything explodes in my face.
After a few beats, he lets go and lowers his gaze to the album. He flips the page, pausing at one particular picture. His fingers trace the edge as if he’s trying to live the moment through the paper.
“She plays the piano?”
Beautifully.
I reach over, flip the page, knowing what’s waiting there. It’s one of my favorites.
He inhales sharply, staring at me and Aria on a piano bench. We took it at her first recital in the fellowship hall of a little church.
He jerks up. “Did you teach her?”
I try to keep my expression neutral. I really do. I don’t want to hurt him by admitting we share one of the most important things to me. Music. But I fail, and my smile breaks free.
“She’s very talented.” I chew on my nail, bracing myself for the next piece of information. “She comes over every Thursday night for piano lessons.”
His eyes widen. “That’s in two days.” His gaze darts to the piano sitting in the corner of the room. “She’ll be here? In this room?”
There’s a shift in his voice. Anticipation. Hope.
It’s terrifying.
This is where boundaries have to exist. Hard ones. Boundaries he might not want. And what will my cousin think? And if he agrees, can I trust Keaton when he’s around her? Is he ready to sit back and be a friend of mine? Will he scare her because I’m sure he won’t be able to stop staring?
Letting him see her in person is an enormous risk. A risk that could unravel everything I’ve sacrificed to keep her safe. But do I have any choice?
“Keaton,” I start.
“Don’t.” He cuts me off, his body tightening as he snaps the album shut. There’s a soft thud on the table when he places it down. A scowl flickers. “Don’t you dare tell me it’s okay for you to see our daughter every week, but I can’t.”