AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Lumberjack in Frosty Falls

Page 9

by Elsie James

Gus takes our order without writing anything down. The jukebox is playing old Christmas songs by Bing Crosby and I can’t help but drown in the nostalgia of being home for Christmas. The music pauses so I fill the silence the way I always do.

I talk through every moment of the event and every inch of the space. Kasper lets me talk never once looking like he can’t wait for me to be done. But he always did let me be myself. His big, rough, careful hands are folded on the table. I watch the little twitch of his mouth at the funny parts.

The fire pops and we share hot toddies before the food comes. I’m only three bites in when Kasper sets down his burger and looks at me. Not the quick look. The long one, it’s a full-inventory type look and I brace myself for whatever’s coming.

“What’s wrong?”

“Why’d you come back, Anya?”

My chest goes tight. “I told you.” I pick at my napkin. “Holiday. Seeing Dad while I’m here. You know this is a temporary break.”

He tilts his head down and looks at me with a raised eyebrow. He doesn’t say anything. But he doesn’t have to. That face says I’ve known you since you were eighteen. Try again.

I take a breath.

“I lost my job.” I’ve said it to exactly two people. Tessa and my old roommate. It doesn’t get easier the third time around. “Then I couldn’t afford my apartment. Then I couldn’t afford the city. It all went at once. Like a stack of chairs.” I make a little falling-over motion with my hand. “And I didn’t know where to go. So I came here.”

There’s a long pause and the words hang heavy between us.

“I’m sorry.”

I can tell he means it. “It’s fine. I’ll figure it out.” I swallow hard.

“You always do.”

I look up.

He’s not smiling. He says it like a plain fact. I don’t know if it’s the drinks or his unwavering faith in me that cracks me right down the middle. But I decide to get brave.

“That Christmas,” I say.

He goes very still.

“When I left for the internship.” My hands are shaking, so I shove them in my lap. “I’ve thought about it a lot over the years. More than I’d like to admit. I’ve stalked you online, kept tabs. You know, made it super weird but only on my end. I mean, thank goodness right. Stopped short of showing up at your house while you were married, so that’s great. But I didn’t imagine you’d ever not be married and…”

“Anya—”

I take a breath. “No. Let me.” I hold up a hand. “I’ve been practicing for ten years. Let me get it out.”

He shuts his mouth and gestures for me to continue.

“I was twenty-two and it felt like the whole world opened up. I could have it all if I was brave enough. I wanted it all.” I swallow. “But I wanted you too.”

I see the muscles in his jaw clench. But I keep going before I lose my nerve.

“So I told myself I could have both even though you didn’t exactly ask me to stay. I always thought I’d go, get settled, build something. And you’d still be here. You were the guy who stays. I’d come back for you when I figured out how to make it work.” My voice wobbles. “Then one year turned into two. Two turned into three.”

I breathe.

“And then you got married.”

He looks down at the table. “I did.”

I didn’t hear it from him. I heard it from a nurse at my father’s care facility. It was too casual, the way you hear about the weather back home. Oh, and that Oakes boy got married. It broke my heart right there on the spot, but I don’t tell him that part.

“I told myself I was happy for you. I compared every single man to you and none of them measured up. But I kept going. Kept working, you know. There wasn’t any turning back at that point. I kept telling myself I made the right choice.” The jukebox clicks over. I don’t hear to what. “Did I?”

He lifts his eyes to mine. And for once, that closed door of a face isn’t closed. There’s something behind it. Something that looks a whole lot like it hurts.