AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Games We Play

Page 88

by Lyra Asher

Scarlett

I’m sorry.

There were so many things I was sorry for. I was sorry for not taking a second and just fucking thinking rather than reacting. I was sorry for not trusting in him, not trusting in us like I promised I would. I was sorry for letting my past dictate my future, my demons stronger than I led on.

Finn, of fucking course, being the saint of a man he was, had immediately responded, his words already easing the ache slightly.

Finnegan

You have nothing to be sorry for, baby.

Even with the apology aired out and my grievances forgiven, I still felt ashamed, and frankly, fucking embarrassed. He was trying so damned hard, doing everything in his power to prove that this could work. And then there was me.

The destroyer of love, the asshole who’d put the ass in assumption.

I felt so much for him, my heart at the edge of bursting every time he was near, but I couldn’t keep the thought that he deserved more from creeping in. He deserved better. Better than me, at least.

Keeping my chin propped on the couch, I watched the two of them discuss Farrah’s wedding plans; dicks and balls were the best comparison for the flowers, it seemed. “Like an orgasmic bouquet of lust.” Farrah’s hazel eyes twinkled with mirth.

“And those little corn dog flower things that are near the lily pads?” Daphne nodded in enthusiasm, her hands moving hastily in front of her to show Farrah the picture she was describing. “That’s the centerpiece; the money shot, if you will.”

“Hey, sweet pea,” Farrah said, head swiveling to my position on the couch, her strappy heels clicking on our floors as she walked. She lifted her bronze hand, her large diamond engagement ring twinkling in the kitchen’s bright light. Then she placed it against my forehead, her voice soft and soothing. “How do you feel?”

Peeling her touch from my face, I shook my head. “I’m not sick, Fare, just wallowing in my own self-pity.”

Farrah clutched her hand to her chest, her lips moving into a shocked expression. “I’m not a doctor, but⁠—”

“Just marrying one,” Daphne piped in as she leaned against the counter, fluffing the flower petals on the most recent arrival.

“But,” our friend continued, her smile wider at the mention of her surgeon fiancé, Dr. Aaron Tearson. “I’d say you were sick with heartbreak, and there is only one cure for that ailment.”

“Dogs?” I queried, both of my hands showcasing the precious creature who was now awake and observing our conversation.

“Not necessarily needed but highly recommended.” Farrah patted the lab mix’s head, Darla’s eyes flicking shut at the lovin’. Daphne rounded the couch, two large grocery bags in her grasp. She began setting out different containers of cured meats, specialty cheeses, and fancy-shaped crackers. “We’re going to have a relaxing night of eating cheese and drinking wine and watching shitty movies.”

My heart warmed at my friends and their thoughtfulness. Farrah wasn’t technically wrong, my heart was hurting, but it wasn’t like she meant it. This wasn’t a normal heartbreak, a he-said-she-said miscommunication.

This was something deeper, something that actually had nothing to do with Finnegan, but with myself. I knew we had to have an unavoidable conversation about what happened when I ran off right after the game. I knew that deep down, what I was running from really had to do with my mother and my fucked up resentment of the past.

Unhealed wounds that you kept pushing down always found a way to rise up again, their pain demanding to be felt. Only I didn’t know how to feel them, how to process the tightness in my throat and the ache in my gut. But I also didn’t know how to turn it off, how to satiate that hunger of despair, the darkness already so familiar.

I was caught in a self-initiated purgatory and falling into the pits of hell, my wings curled in and refusing to release. However, when I was with Finn, it felt like heaven was just mere inches away, my soul yearning to stay in his all-encompassing warmth and light. Just like my arms snaked around my middle to hold all the pieces together, my wings were also pinned in their constraint, an unyielding shield for my heart. That protective barrier had kept me guarded and grounded for years, but now I could see that it was also preventing me from flying.

Shifting on the couch, I pressed a pillow to my lap for support. “Though I appreciate your guys’ sentiment, I’m okay. I⁠—”

“No,” Daphne held up her manicured fingers in a stop motion, her brown eyes cutting me with a glare. “You’re not okay.” That made me sit up a little straighter, the cushion now clutched against my chest. “You’re just scared and that’s okay.”

Farrah gathered three wine glasses and began setting the coffee table as Daphne continued. “But not everybody wants to hurt you or use you. Not everybody is your mother.” Her words sliced into my gut, the pain spilling out in a current of agony. Daph always saw the light in people, their positive attributes to society rather than the murkiness I searched for. This wasn’t the first time we’d had this conversation over our years of friendship, but it felt different this time, the revelation sinking into my skin the more she went on.

“You’re freaking out because of a possibility. Your brain is rushing to its own fucked up conclusions, because that’s what you do, Scarlett. You overthink and react. Your first instinct is to run before anyone has the chance to hurt you, but what makes Finn so different from me?” Her large brown eyes were full of tenderness and understanding. “What makes him different from Farrah or from Addison?”

Her question took me by surprise, my jaw dropping as my mind reeled for an answer. “What do you mean? You’re my friends. That’s completely different.”

“Friends can still hurt each other, and you know that.” Farrah gave me a scathing look, her own memories of shit friends in her youth coming forth. “But you’ve never abandoned us, Scar. You’d never run for the hills if I forgot an important dinner or if Daphne made a mistake. You know we love you and that we can hurt you, but you don’t run. You know that we’re capable of making mistakes and you’re capable of forgiveness. So, what makes him so different from us?” It felt like the air was steadily being sucked from the room, my breath slowing as the revelation came forth. “He doesn’t want to hurt you; He doesn’t want anything from you but you.”

I was silent for a whole minute. The only sound was the wine filling the glasses before Daphne spoke. “And we all know he means the world to you.” Her soft hand pressed against my arm that was clutching the pillow like a lifeline.

Finn meant more than the world to me. He meant everything to me and that was why I was so afraid. He hadn’t even cheated on me, and we all saw how horribly wrong that went. I couldn’t even imagine the damage that would come if he had. But I also couldn’t imagine a world where I kept living like this. Like a hollow, hopeless creature shrinking into darkness, fearful of the sun’s heavenly rays of enlightenment.