Page 84
One of Finnegan’s arms snaked out to the medium-height woman with light brown hair who stood by his side. Everett’s eyes were focused on her as he laughed loudly at something she said. The walls began closing in around me, the room getting entirely too small as Finn tugged her into his side closely, his own shoulders shaking from laughter.
My breathing became shallow and quick, heart pounding erratically in my chest. The side of his chiseled jaw was on full display when his head turned slightly. My steps halted, my feet suddenly feeling like cement.
Every breath of air was a battle, the clamor around me deafening as Finnegan leaned down and pressed a soft kiss to the stranger’s head.
The betrayal was a disease, a nimble moving plague that began running through my veins. I thought I knew what pain felt like before, but this, this was an entirely different affliction.
The butterflies that fluttered in my core, the same ones Finnegan grew and cherished, immediately died in my chest, my heart turning to ice. Rage mixed with suffering and thrashed around in my body, its claws slicing my core. This hurt inside of me was too much, every breath coming in short and shaky gasps. The room was spinning, the tunnel narrowing into the size of a straw as the past reared its ugly head, and my mother’s words of hatefulness spun in my mind.
You’re nothing but a mistake.
An unwanted nuisance.
The words were a knife through my cold heart, its sharp blade twisting and turning between each panicked beat. My skin felt like it was stretched too tight, legs turning to jelly as I fought back the tremors. I couldn’t control the cacophony of her bitterness that filled me, the continuous string of pure loathing at my existence.
I should’ve just gotten rid of you when I had the chance.
And once again, like many times throughout my childhood, I wished she had.
Guiliana Alessandro had said things like that all the time, her intense rage knowing no bounds. With her foul words aimed to slice and maim, they sunk into my skin, into my subconsciousness over the years I was trapped in her hellish grasp. No matter what I did, it was never enough for her. No amount of awards and trophies or high grades made her want me, made her love me.
The hurt still came at the end of the day, the darkness bleeding into the next until all I knew was that ache.
It made me feel utterly worthless, her expectations insurmountable.
That same, familiar sensation crept in, a heavy weight threatening to crush me as anxiety tightened in my chest. If only I were as cold as I pretended to be, then this wouldn’t have been so hard.
So fucking painful.
The last time Finnegan made me feel like this was when I’d thought that maybe our friendship was growing into something more, just after he was drafted to the professional league. We were still in contact at that point; just some lingering texts here and there, from opposite sides of the country with him at Princeton and me at SFSU. So when he was drafted by the Bisons, I was beyond ecstatic.
My Finn was moving to my city. He was going to be there, close to me again.
It was like the stars were aligning.
So I congratulated him, of course, and off we went.
Endless texts, phone calls, and Facetimes between the weeks it took him to move to his new city. There was nothing overtly sexual, since we were still toeing the line of something more, but we both knew what was promised between the lines—at least I thought we both knew.
Until I got that damned message; the one simple sentence that had shattered my soul and made me feel as rejected as I did now.
Finnegan MacCallum
You’re nothing but an unwanted nuisance.
I was stripped bare, all my wounds on display for the world to see, when I read those words. He knew what they would do to me; my confession of my mother’s cruel taunting was one of the secrets I’d shared in our early youth.
Unwanted. Nuisance.
Like a slap to the face, my skin and heart ached from the harsh onslaught. Now, that same awareness washed over me, drowning me in its sludgy, angry waves. A hot tear began to fall and I batted it away quickly, the world coming back to me full force as Finn kept his arm wrapped around the random woman.
He didn’t even notice my presence just yards away.
That slamming realization sent another slice through my abdomen.
“Hey, Scarlett …” a tender voice prodded, my gaze snapping to Theodore Maddox’s. His signature golden-framed glasses hung from his nose, concern written in his light brown eyes as he asked, “You okay?”
“Yup.” My voice was high and strained. I didn’t look back over to Finnegan. I couldn’t. It would only make me cry, and I couldn’t do that. Not here. Not now. Not when I’d just found out I had been yet another game that Finn was playing, my broken and battered heart his prize. My teeth bared into a false smile, but Theo clearly didn’t buy it as I bit out, “Just peachy keen. Goodnight.”