Page 77
I’d never known what peace felt like, my life a tumultuous circus of one-sided love and war-like chaos.
But presently, I was happier than I’d ever been, doing my best to ignore the nagging voice that told me my happiness had an expiration date. The man who’d sent the horrific message that left me shattered all those years ago was nowhere in sight. In his place was the human embodiment of sunshine.
Even just the thought of those cruel words spilling from his lips seemed so foreign, so wrong coming from the Finn I’d always known. He was no longer some cocky asshole stuck on the high of accomplishing his dream; a match in his hand, at the ready to burn all the bridges from his past.
Instead, he was my Finn.
My kind, annoyingly thoughtful, and pestersome Finn who knew what he wanted and didn’t hesitate making it known to the entire world. The same boy who’d tucked dandelions behind my ear and whispered “so pretty,” with a soft and soothing voice that the wind could barely hear.
And now, with his reassuring words washing over me, my nerves calmed and the demons silenced, I began to think true peace may feel a lot like Finnegan Killian MacCallum.
For that moment, I forgot all about our doubt-riddled past and my useless list of reasons why this shouldn’t work. Why we shouldn’t have even been trying when all that waited on the other end was pain.
The inevitability of heartbreak.
“I don’t want to run from this.” My voice was soft, but the words were sure and true. “I don’t want to run from us anymore.” Finn’s answering smile was brilliant and charming, both of his dimples on full display. As charming as it was, it was equal parts heartbreaking because beneath that golden glow and boyish mask, I could see the vulnerability lurking in his gaze.
I could see the slight hesitation beneath the surface.
He was scared, too; possibly just as much as me.
In the glimpse of that second I realized, I definitely didn’t want to run away anymore.
At least not from him. Not from the future, or what could be, even if it was filled with nothing but darkness.
No, I was no longer running away from my future, tail tucked like a scared, stray dog.
I was running straight toward it, the sun lighting my path as I left my doubts in the dust.
CHAPTER EIGHTEEN
scarlett
“Holy fuck,” Finnegan breathed out, his tall frame leaning against my eclectic bedroom’s doorway. I smirked in the mirror, trying to fight the blush forming on my cheeks as I finished my lip liner. My fingers and wrists were covered in gold jewelry and stacked necklaces were wrapped around my neck like I’d just raided a treasure chest. I wore thick black eyeliner with a sensual smoky eye, the darkness of the pigmented shadow making the blue in my eyes practically glow.
With a final snug to the red bandana tied around my skull, I’d say I was as good as ready.
The flowy skirt of my white mini dress swished when I turned around, the matching golden chains around my corset-adorned waist clinking in tune with the movement. With a hand over his heart, Finn pretended to stagger as his smoldering eyes roamed over my Halloween costume.
Keira Knightley in Pirates of the Caribbean had been one of my bisexual awakenings—and possibly most of the world population’s awakening, because, hello? She was the fucking Pirate King, and that title alone should have been enough to bring any person to their knees in worship. As everybody else fawned over Orlando Bloom and his abs, I was drooling for Elizabeth Swan, my love for pirates blooming under the flames of lust.
In an homage to the Pirate King herself, Finn and I decided to dress up as treasure hunting, rum drinking, loudmouthed sailors for this year’s Halloween. We were about to head out to The Box. The Bisons had won their game against Pittsburgh 4-2 just under an hour ago. Most of his teammates were already at the club celebrating—Spencer, Daphne’s boyfriend, included.
Daph and I sprinted home after the game’s final buzzer, her excitement for her surprise costume palpable. We’d only had two days to prepare, our costume ideas coming to us belatedly like most of the Halloweens we’d spent together. This year, my outfit had been easy enough to scrounge up from my closet, what with my love for vintage fashion and random sparkly treasures. My roommate-slash-best friend had to make one final mad dash to the corner store for a last-minute accessory, leaving Finn and me alone.
“You look ...” Finnegan’s jaw was practically unhinged, charcoal eyeliner making his gaze all the darker as he watched me in awe. His white linen shirt was unbuttoned dangerously low, the sharp angles and valleys of his muscles exposed as the fabric billowed. There was a vibrant crimson scarf tied around his waist like a belt, his black pants tucked into worn leather boots that seemed far too nice to be costume.
Finnegan MacCallum looked mouthwateringly delicious; a ripe apple I wanted to take a big ole bite out of.
It was like he’d stepped out of one of my twisted fairytale fantasies, one where he would steal me away and lock me in his ship for all of eternity.
I may have been drooling, my jaw going slack as he ran a calloused hand through his hair, removing the bandana that matched mine.
Fuck, I loved when his hair got messy like that.
Like I was the one running my fingers through it wildly.
“Angel.” Finn’s breathing was labored and my knees began to feel wobbly and weak. The tiny golden hoop dangling from his ear glinted in my low bedroom light as he prowled toward me. “You are so fucking gorgeous.”