AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

The Games We Play

Page 66

by Lyra Asher

“I like him,” I gritted my teeth and repeated with flared nostrils. Daph was grinning now, her pearly whites on full display in a show of pride. “I actually like him, okay?”

The mortification of the moment hit me like an avalanche, my verbal admission making it all the more real and cumbersome.

Fuck.

I threw a multicolored blanket over my head, shutting myself off from the world. In my cocoon of warmth, I could still hear Daphne’s light voice. “And this is bad?”

Flinging the linen back down, my black hair stuck to the fibers and shot up in a crazed spiky ‘do. “This is the WORST!” I screeched.

All I had ever learned from emotions that ran this deep was pain; pain that didn’t just up and vanish. It was a torment that lingered no matter how much I pushed it away.

I liked him.

I really fucking liked him.

And that’s what scared me the most.

“You’ve seemed different since you started talking to him, Scar.” Daphne began smoothing my hair down with a tender touch. “And different isn’t always bad. You’ve seemed happier … I don’t know.” She shook her head, trying to find the right words. “Lighter, almost.”

“Lighter?” I questioned as she leaned back into the couch.

She nodded, her beautiful face relaxed and at ease, like my happiness was hers too. “It’s just something I’ve noticed.”

Beyond all that hurt and despair and the lingering sadness that reminded me to not trust again, there was something else waiting. There was something glittering, shiny and eager, in that eclipsing darkness.

It felt almost akin to hope.

“But what if I’m scared?” I whispered and looked down at my hands clutching the glass. “I don’t want to be vulnerable …” My breath was shaky as I whispered, “Not like that.”

“Being vulnerable is the most courageous thing you can do,” my best friend chirped, but her sentiment didn’t hit its mark.

Stomach twisting in knots, the next question felt like acid on my tongue as I spoke it, but I no longer held back my deepest fear. “What if he hurts me again?”

Peeking back up to see her expression, I was shocked to see she was still smiling. With her large brown eyes sparkling, I saw that hope simmering in my chest reflected back at me. Her voice was delicate but the words rang strong and true. “What if he doesn’t?”

Finnegan MacCallum had cracked the icy shield I built around my heart, but there were still shards embedded, the hurt deep and robust with every inhale. I didn’t know how to get them out, to let my heart heal once and for all. But for that quick second when I caught Finn’s smile on the screen, I swear I could feel those fragments melting, Daphne’s question on a loop in my jumbled mind.

Most Eligible Douche

I need to see you tonight. I miss your voice and pretty face.

An hour after mine and Daph’s dinner, I was laying in bed, reading about hot aliens with flexible tails when the text popped across my screen. Finn was still on the East Coast, a grand total of three hours ahead of our time, so I figured he would be out with his team either celebrating their win or sleeping by now. After his little knighting ceremony in my honor during the game, we exchanged a few texts, my heart fluttering all the way into my throat from his sweet words.

I wasn’t planning on calling him again like I had a few nights ago, my nerves getting the best of me. My fingers flew over the keyboard, rapidly typing out some excuse because I was still just a big ball of anxiety. Before I could hit send, his contact flashed front and center, his incoming call interrupting me.

“Shit,” I muttered to myself, gnawing on my lower lip again. Blowing out a breath, I sat up in bed and mussed my pillow-dented tendrils. I was only going to answer for a minute to tell him I had to go to bed and then that was it.

Answering the call, I faked a yawn and immediately began rattling off my excuse. “Hey Dimples, I’m actually about to fall asleep and I⁠—”

His handsome face filled my screen, the words dying on my lips as I took him in.

His brown hair was wet and disheveled, the messy strands freshly washed from his shower. His tanned and muscular skin was on full display with little water droplets still dotting it, not a shirt in sight. God, his neck was so thick and peppered lightly with hair, the five o’clock shadow moving all the way to his chiseled jaw. Those predatory eyes were watching me with rapt attention, his plush lips drawn up as he purred, “Hey, baby. I missed you.”

The tension in my shoulders eased from the cadence of his voice, so dark and sultry yet so inviting. He always conveyed so much intimacy with his voice. Just a simple “hey” from him felt like he was calling me his “good girl” all over again.

I couldn’t stop the smile from peeling across my lips as I responded, “I missed you, too.”

His grin turned teasing, his shadowy eyes squinting. “You don’t look all that tired to me, you little liar. Are you trying to get out of this before it even begins?” he tsked at me like I was a petulant child while clicking his tongue.